ToS Mafia - Day 8 - (3/19) [Town wins!]

[Wazza]

@darth_tabor

/ok I guess this is happening/

/vote jake

What the fuck is this post?

What the actual fuck?

[PoisonedSquid]

Meta isn’t something we can control on our own. Sure, scum can try to fake their town meta, but there’s times where they’re displaying their scumtell without realizing it

[sulit]

The minute darth is scumread or mentioned they pop on, say they’re going to do things or give reads everyone has said before, then leave until it happens again.

But sure, they’re town.

[JakeTheWolfie]

That might usually be the case, but we have no idea if it applies to any particular person in any given game.

[sulit]

Not to mention Jake is defending them for who knows what reason??

[JakeTheWolfie]

I do think Darth is scum, but my vote feels better placed on Marshal “lockwolf” Marshal

[clonedcheese]

@JakeTheWolfie

I… don’t know how Marshal can do this. I ask them a genuine question and they respond with… not answering at all.

Uh maybe a little more civil conversation was required.

Just looking at this interaction between Jake and Marshal, I’dhighly doubt W/W. And frankly, I don’t know if I see any scum-AI in either one.

@JakeTheWolfie

Explain whether a supposed chainsaw that you think you felt always must 100% come from scum, or if it comes from a townie that genuinely thinks you are scum and it was just an unfortunate coincidence that it felt like chainsawing.

this is like the definition of strawmanning, misrepresenting someone’s argument to get it to seem bad. Maybe that’s why Marshal’s not answering your question

@Wazza

What the fuck is this post?

What the actual fuck?

language
This was an OMGUS I think

[JakeTheWolfie]

Defending? When did I defend them?

[sulit]

Saw it when I was reading up, one second.

[PoisonedSquid]

That’s true, but old habits die hard. If their habits haven’t changed, we can still use them to read someone unless if they managed to fake their meta completely

[JakeTheWolfie]

@clonedcheese

this is like the definition of strawmanning, misrepresenting someone’s argument to get it to seem bad.

Why did marshal not answer my question on how to improve my question for them and instead left the thread entirely?

[sulit]

Ooo my phone is at one percent

OH LOOK DARTH POPPED IN WOW

[Wazza]

I feel like I should post my readlist to make things clear to y’all that I’m lurking.

[darth_tabor]

Hey some people actually have things to do in the real world. Please refrain from using my activity as evidence because it has nothing to do with the current game situation

[JakeTheWolfie]

You… just proved their point.

Someone said you were scum, you just so happen to appear in the thread.

[sulit]

I think you’re lurking. It has nothing to do with how often you’re here, it’s when you pop in and what you do.

[darth_tabor]

Agh your point is proven by the timing of my calc quiz

ooo very evidence

[clonedcheese]

continuously picking on someone through strawmanning is not a very great experience, and honestly if you did that to me I’d have quit too

Your argument is “I wasn’t chainsawing Arete, I just happened to be suspicious of you, so your suspicion of me doesn’t make sense”
You may have don’t better to just say that outright and not say anything about chainsaw + scum-AI thing. That’s the strawman part

[sulit]

Except it’s happened before

[darth_tabor]

And hi yes it’s called protecting myself? Bc I don’t actually want to be lynched?