Because from my point of view I know Marshal is evil
Just because you were looking at retrain possibility first doesnāt mean itās suddenly not their theory?
1 Like
I created more with the idea you brought up, making it my theory. Youāre acting like Blizzard taking copyright claims off peopleās custom maps
My theory was that maybe retrained mafia would claim being roleblocked too.
They didnāt.
Now Squid says I was retrained and claimed it.
Thatās pretty much same theory, just putting exact names into it.
That doesnāt help anyone else parse this though
Ok but you never stated this theory anywhere
squid didnāt steal your idea just had the same one
I mean, I agree that what you brough up is a possibility.
Possibility which I didnāt think through, cause I do know that roleblock is real.
So no, I didnāt really follow up on roleblock being fake and how this would build up.
You never mentioned that a mafia could advocate for another mafia claiming a certain thing happen to them
Cause in this particular case noone else claimed roleblocked.
However I did simlar thing with me sayin gthat Arete didnāt have to be witched, they could just claim being witched after another mafia member was.
This way witch would know 2 mafia members at once.
In general in this setup you should NEVER claim being doused and NEARLY NEVER claim witched.
Both are -EV.
Tho I understand that Arete had to, especially with Marshal thunderome thing.
Bepwei couldāve lied about being pranked to make us think there is a Prankster and make us assume the Mafia is:
Capogreienrienr thing
Mafia Support
Prankster
Consort
Just a theory.
1 Like
also I thought doused people didnāt know they were doused but I guess thatās kind of beside the point since thereās no Arso
who is scum right now
Exactly cause this scenario was being used very often in this setup.
Or even better:
Mafia does not claim witched, but insteadā¦ Witch does.
In that case witch knows they witched scum and whole scumteam knows witch.