Are you saying Arete’s the witch and Marshal’s Mafia?
In general I’m saying that you are missing a lot of scenarios.
Ones which make sense for scum to do, cause they get a lot of added value from that.
At htis case, maybe, maybe not.
Witch is rather prone to claim invest, not sheriff.
I fanything I’m rather prone to first case, aka mafia teammate claiming witched instead of mafia which really was witched.
Arete would freely kill who they want (Derps), while real mafia member was redirected to… you for example?
That makes sense. While witching to Derps… does not.
I’m talking about more likely theories that could benefit scum in the long run. That doesn’t mean going through every single scenario possible
I’m talking about scenarios which could be used to pass information to witch.
This does benefit scum… a lot.
Like this scenarios do.
Talking probably too, if it was like it is rn… I doubt anyone really would go deep enough to notice them.
Maybe except scum.
Ehh… better to have it in the open than to overlook obvious signals anyway.
Also, If the last PRish person which flies around here and there, looking like they want to claim and backing off a moment later claims TP… I’m gonna laugh.
But yeah.
I really wanna argue some more, but I used my brain too hard. Can someone else do it for me? :^)
Yes, the last post is me saying I do consider one more PR in certain place.
My bet is on TP, but I can be wrong rolewise.
Thing is that they are townier than you @PoisonedSquid
I mean, my theory comes from the ground that I know I was really roleblocked.
I didn’t think about Cheese claiming it as prankster.
I din’t have to.
Your theory does stand ground, just not in my world.
What we know:
Eevee claims Roleblocked.
Cheese claims Roleblocker.
We have no way of verifying whether or not Eevee or Cheese is lying.
1 Like
Yeah, because only “you” know if you’ve been roleblocked or not. (I guess Cheese can count, but immunity is a thing) My theory’s better because it has no bias towards it and it better explains Bepwei’s result of being attacked and healed because if he got attacked and you got occed, there’s no way Prankster can do both
If we kill Cheese and they don’t flip anything significant (Not Consort/Escort), Eevee is a liar, or the real Roleblocker hasn’t claimed.
If we kill Cheese and they flip consort, Eevee is more or less confirmed. Not entirely, as Eevee could’ve just claimed RBd and Cheese flipping consort with a claimed RB on a town would look great for Eevee.
If we kill Cheese and they flip Escort, then we haven’t idea.
If we kill Eevee, then regardless of what they flip, we cannot determine anything from cheese.