ToS2399 - ɢᴀᴍᴇ ᴛʜʀᴇᴀᴅ - ɢᴀᴍᴇ ᴏᴠᴇʀ [ᴍᴀꜰɪᴀ ᴡɪɴꜱ] - ᴀᴡ ꜱʜɪᴛ, ʜᴇʀᴇ ᴡᴇ ɢᴏ ᴀɢᴀɪɴ

[Geyde]

[Simon]

again im speaking from your perspective where light can be town or scum not mine where light has to be scum

[Centuries]

dunno

idk im lost

[an_gorta_pratai]

I think out of Simon and Light that Light is always scummier here tbqh

[Simon]

yeah but why do you think that tho
dont get me wrong not disagreeing
but why

[Apprentice]

did we looser now

[Centuries]

we havent

unless its datbird sulit

[Simon]

havent lost yet
at least 1 scum between myself and light

[an_gorta_pratai]

I think you are in the PoE for sure, but Light is also PoE and his claim can easily be faked by scum

[Centuries]

whats more likely

its W/W and there’s 1 scum in marshal sulit datbird

or

its W/V and there’s 2 scum in marshal sulit datbird

hnghh

[Apprentice]

gorta can you explain to me in depth why you voted light>simon. I just wanna hear the thoughts behind it again even if you’ve said it over the course of things before. Like a post on how you’ve read both of them and why you made this choice. If it takes a while that’s fine

[Centuries]

It’s W/W isn’t it

[Marshal]

@Simon

@Marshal

My approach to arete this game in public and in DMs has been to have the mindset of TMIing them town and pocketing them

I basically have approached arete in specific as w marshal would approach v arete

I haven’t faked any reads discussed with them but I have been deliberately trying to pocket them multiple times and it has worked

my theory has been, basically, that if I can do my regular wolf strategy of “appeal to arete and predict what they think and use this to pocket them” and like… successfully do this, it should prove V arete as arete is very unlikely to be able to fake being pocketed by me and make posts that I can expect them to make.

I’ve looked over interactions and determined that arete is like, 99% town here.

I have like on 4 or 5 seperate occasions deliberately made pocket attempts on arete and predicted exactly how they’d respond to certain posts

I think this is like really hard to fake from them, especially because I have told nobody that I have been doing this and it’s really weird for a wolf to anticipate that

I think my problem with reading arete when i’ve misread them is not like strongly considering v!arete worlds and what v!arete would actually say

and I thought by getting myself into like the mindset of v!arete and predict exactly what they will post that I can just be sure on arete v.

I’ve analysed this afterwards without pretending to have TMI arete v and I stand hard by my conclusions

tl;dr: most of my posting towards arete has been trying to pocket them. I’ve succeeded and this makes me feel like arete is just super likely to be villager as I don’t think it’s possible for them to be fake pocketed by me when having no way to anticipate this.

@Arete I want your thoughts on this

and if you ever picked up on this

god im super torn on this
cause one part of me just loves the approach and the multitudinal psychology of it all,
but the other part of me is just thinking, remembering the post where marshal said he was a wolf, and predicted you wouldn’t like it because marshal likes to gloat.
marshal likes to gloat
wolf marshal can predict town!arete
both of these are established.
wouldnt this all be the biggest gloat , admitting he’s using his wolf-play on you, saying hes using it to see if arete’s town, but in actuality is just one giant meta-pocket?

@Mistyx

I’m going to snapread this thought as villagery glgl

@Arete

this feels like a villagery thought probably

god this is my biggest hangup on simon

I’m like ~90% sure that both simon and light are wolves

It’s just
This is handled in a villagery way

@Simon

i can send a bit more in pm’s if those ever open back up if you want

and the fact that he like went to arete with it is not bad either

The screenshot could be doctored (It’s in arete’s general like typing style but that’s not unfakeable) so i’m not going to hard stand by this but I dunno

I don’t hate how he handled this
I also don’t really hate how light has handled lylo

just
mmmmmMMMM

[Marshal]

yeah i’ve already been through this just replace marshal with you

I think it’s w/w so yeah thats a thing

[Aelin]

[Apprentice]

I think gorta/simon being w/w with light v is a real possibility here. I want gorta to walk me through his vote thoughts though before I jump down a rabbit hole like that

[Marshal]

@an_gorta_pratai

/vote Light I think this is the right way

hmmmmmmmmM

gimm a sec

[Simon]

man for a good second i thought you were calling me scum for that and we were about to have words

[Centuries]

it’d be way easier if we could just yeet gorta tbh lol

[Marshal]

tbh

gorta voting on the wagons makes me think that it’s w/w