I’m not even confident in a Town Seth read
I just didn’t want to hardcore defend him because my points were a vague meta read and a wagon composition which i disliked 40% of
because odds are he mightve flipped scum and was an intended bus
past 2 games he randed scum and had level 0 reads all game long and then this game he had made 2 or so not-level 0 reads which i found quite hard for sda to emulate just because of what his wim would look like if he randed scum 3 times in a row
Same logic applies with me thinking you are scum. You are also more competent as scum. That’s an unfair treatment of the point.
And also i had already made the argument on Surge right before you replaced in, it’s coincedimce, fuck mobile typing.
my line of thought went like
if he cant emulate a non gut read in harry potter where scum quite literally swept the entire town
no way he does it here
quote them for me?
all his reads that I’d noticed so far seemed like classic Derps gutreads but I was also skimming
well see this is one of the things I was trying to get you to clarify so that I could evaluate the likelihood of my tinfoil actually being correct
(like specifically villagers tend to care more than wolves about whether people are actually listening to their posts)
yeah ik whatever its 2 reads and 2 rest but i just quoted what i liked
kinda like if i was a child nad u told me i could purchase whatever i wanted at a toy store
okay
I disagree that those are out of Derps’s scumrange but your read itself seems basically fine from a ‘what alignment are you, Centuries’ perspective
I just got to this post that Centuries quoted and it happened after Centuries made the read on Derps
(I know that you were going to say that but honestly looking back the early derps reads kinda suck but looking back my original argument applies)
(thats the part i liked at first, its a solic read but it doesnt really hold up)
I don’t wanna spoil anything 
although he specifically follows up in the thread a couple posts later by calling it out as a reason to townread him
which is consistent with how he answered my question earlier
I don’t know why we are still focusing on mechanics, but that should always be left to night vigs/day vigs.
Define cult in this scenario
I don’t think this game would contain that many confirmable town roles. It seems too town sided, so someone is likely evil out of those 3.
Is that always the case though? coughs in SFoL 64 Maybe I can just imitate my town meta though