also cream i’m not sure
i think most people are going to say they are obviously town but i haven’t seen anything that strikes the marl brain as them being town yet
that is to say
common sense probably says they are towny
but my uncommon sense isn’t convinced yet
I don’t think that they’re lying about their experience as this isn’t an alt situation ala Esooa claiming that Alison is Marcistar, so with Cream’s experience in mind I don’t think that she’s likely rand >W.
She’s behind Cent/Vul/Chloe for me, but still.
Thread in general feels mostly villagery. Wouldn’t be surprised if like 2-3 of the wolves are in Silviu/Zone/Phraze/LiL/Psyx/Appel.
that’s fair and i can see where you’re coming from but my brain is built different
i don’t let myself townread the innocent-ey sounding tone and long posts because i’ve been burned by it one too many times
if they’re town i’ll find something towny to me and if i dont i’ll eventually find something wolfy and bury them
So this is kind of late and kinda not relevant to what’s being discussed right now, but I had a thought regarding that long back-and-forth about who the better wolf was between Alice/Centuries/Chloe/etc. I think Alice was really adamant about being the best wolf with some really high scum winrate. And I feel like if Alice was scum, she wouldn’t be driving in that point so hard. Like, as wolf, why would you want to brag about how good your scumgame is and make everyone paranoid af about you? I feel like wolves would just be like, “lol yeah my scumgame ain’t that hot” and want to be a little underestimated.
Then I guess you just have an ego about your wolfgame 
1 Like
uh no
it is NAI 100% for her
if she’s town she’d do it and if she were scum she’d also do it
Pigeon kinda seems to be trying to interact with the content, even if his posts have been ???.
LiLi… really hasn’t done much and her reaction to you pressuring her is bleh.
Got it got it… I accept that my reads are prob gonna be trash this game due to not really having meta on you guys, but I’ll try my best.
Honestly on reading her posts with the context of the thread she actually looks kinda worse being that there was plenty of content for her to interact with while she was online and she choose not to.
In our first discussion regarding pigeon, you say that he’s more of a go-getter, more proactive, and more aggressive as a villager.
Now you say that you unvote him because he’s trying to interact with the content. The most I see is him doing an ISO on you and then making basic reads on Marl, Chloe, Cent, and me. I think he hasn’t really been aggressive or proactive, except maybe in regards to you a little. IDK why you are giving him a pass so easily just because he interacted with some content. I think a good number of his posts are responses to people, which is more passive than proactive in my mind.
I feel like there’s a discrepancy in how you said you would initially read pigeon and how you later on did. Is there something I’m missing here?
2 Likes
More or less because in his wolfgame he kind of just doesn’t exist.
Him just OMGUS’ing me over it feels closer to his towngame where he’ll often just OMGUS people for dumb reasons where as a wolf he kind of… just keeps on not existing.
Eh, not really. Aggressiveness/Passiveness is just one metric that I use to evaluate him. I feel like Pidgeon’s basically sitting between both of his ranges where he isn’t strongly villagery nor strongly wolfy as well.
If he keeps being useless then I’m fine with chopping him but I’m not going to waste the entire day on him as I have like 8 people in my PoE that I need to evaluate.
One more question… can you expand on this? In what way is her reaction “bleh”?