Oh yeah, cloned also never mentioned City and his only interaction with Nuclear seemed TMI-ish on them being V. So if cloned is a wolf, Squirrel is definitely just a PR.
if you think cloned might be a villager, do you think any of his reads have merit to them?
I mean heās been scumreading me for days and youāve been townreading me for days so I donāt really know how that works out
Already went over this read being really bad.
Yeah.
I actually really dislike how quickly min reaches the bolded conclusion. It doesnāt feel like there was any thought given to it. Both flipped V, so wolf!min never had a reason to care. Could explain the lack of visible thought.
This is okay.
But this is really bad, like I said before. The language min uses implies these are all villagers. Which they are, but thatās the exact problem. Itās a weird language choice for someone with no TMI. Itās the language choice of someone who knows these people are villagers. Itās implicitly assuming two things: that pigeon is LHF and that the āconsensusā is wrong. For all min knows, cloned could be right, except for his read on min, soā¦ Why not even entertain that?
I donāt think min has given this slot any thought beyond that statement.
Min is still harping on this idea that the consensus is incorrect. They never provide a reason why itās incorrect. Sure, they townread Leafia, thatās fine, but I think itās still weird. I donāt know. The Leafia townread beforehand that min defended actually makes this look less egregious, but still. It looks like min is chainsawing cloned.
This is a weird consideration for someone who townread Leafia super early, and against consensus to boot.
Thatās true! I think the comment itself is NAI, though.
I think this is a villagery thought. I also think I said this before.
Eh, Iām starting to think min is implying a weird townread here. Still wouldāve preferred to see it outright stated, but.
These posts donāt unalign these two. But at least they interacted. Thatās more than I can say for peopleās treatment of City. This is the third ISO Iām reading, and only one had any semblance of acknowledging City was in this game.
This is randomly shading me for no reason. Maybe because I pushed on them earlier? Interesting how they donāt vote me there. Iām probably oversensitive to this because itās my wagon, but still.
I dislike the narrow focus. There should be a wider focus at this point, instead of this one wolfread.
Speaking of which.
But Iāmā¦ confused by the later posting. Min calls January a wolf and then doesnāt say anything about it. I think it was a joke?
Ah, yes, the fabled City interaction.
Acknowledging Zone! Finally, someone does it!
Oh, so now min thinks cloned couldāve been bussing, but only one partner. I actually think this is villagery. This shows that min genuinely thought about it for a while. Wolf!min could write this off as an incorrect push and keep shoving the same points, that itās nonsensical and potentially agenda. I even agree that itās a really bad push, but minās thinking about it.
Itās one of the rare cases of genuine thought I see in this ISO this far. But they are there.
This post is really weird. Itās like theyāre contemplating scumreading me for fun, not because of an actual read.
Their treatment of my slot is weird in general. They argue with me when I question their Leafia read, then they kinda skirt around talking to me. I donāt think Iām qualified to figure out if itās wolfy, though. Itās my slot. Maybe thatās exactly why I could figure it out, but. Eh.
Iāll be honest - I donāt even remember what minās talking about. But to their credit, this doesnāt look made up.
Given this, min voting Marl two days later looks bad, but they were saving themselves, so.
This is better.
I meanā¦ sure?
This is min noticing the dreadful post January wrote about killing Windward tomorrow if Silviuās town. Min noticing it right away and appropriately responding is a very good look for min.
I forgot I called this villagery as a snap reaction. Past me was an idiot. Min even argued with me on it, thatās a very good look.
Why did I defend him?
Why did I convince min to listen to me? Now I feel like Iām dumb. Iām reading back and I agree with what minās doing here.
I donāt mind them listening to me here because they said in between the posts I quoted that they were turning around on my slot. They were considering that they were scumreading me because of OMGUS and nothing more.
Same.
This waffling is kinda villagery. I read the first post and I was like āyou just listened to what I said about January,ā but then minās like āmaybe notā so Iām like āokay, thatās fine.ā
But thereās still a problem. Minās considering voting Leafia here and I donāt see where their Leafia read changed. Why suddenly consider voting Leafia? I mean, I know you also townread people like Marl, but.
ā¦Interesting?
Interesting.
I donāt recall min ever pushing Windward for pushing the Silviu/Whysper yeet. I guess min has changed their mind since then?
Min still thinking about it is villagery, I think. And by thinking about it, I mean coming up with different theories. I donāt think a wolf would bother here. They are already voting a town.
I think this end of day is very villagery. The emotion feels real. Caveat being that Iāve miscleared wolves on emotion before.
Overall, minās day 1 is actually not as bad as I remember. Thereās plenty of questionable stuff early on, but what they do later is perfectly fine. In places, itās also pretty villagery. Highlights include continuously coming back to what cloned said and analyzing it from different perspectives. They also include an emotionally charged end of day, where several townreads of theirs got wagoned.
I think min actually has more going for them than cloned does, and cloned has more going for him than January does. And January isnāt aligned with cloned.
Iām starting to become partial to wolfteams with January/Zone/City.
His push on you is one of the main things giving me pause. It feels like heās incessantly tunneling you because thatās the wolf wincon. But then again, why wonāt he push me? Iām a much easier misyeet here. People are paranoid of my wolfgame. I never thought Iād say that, actually, that makes me feel funny.
Looking at it independently, I would actually say itās min>cloned>January in order from villageriest to wolfiest. Which is funny, because I expected the polar opposite going in.
Itās really messing up my worlds, though.
Like, if Iām wrong on Windward and Windward just played a hell of a game, then Iām a clown for letting this happen again after Marshal in RWBY.
If Windwardās actually mafia with, like, City, then Iām actually abysmal at this game.
She keeps talking about how Iām pocketing her, but I donāt feel like Iāve ever done that?
well, you shouldnāt be trusting my reads at the very least because theyāve actually been awful
But youāre the only other person solving the game and looking at it holistically, except maybe Squirrel. Everyone else is just pushing a preestablished agenda, I said this before. I donāt feel like I have anyone else to interact with when nobody will budge or build consensus.
I tried to talk to other people today and I donāt feel like I accomplished anything with it. We donāt even have a voting order for tomorrow. I feel like whichever villager is pushing their agenda is going to snapvote and weāre gonna lose the game because Iām not communicating well enough.
well, same here, itās mostly just been us solving in the thread and quite honestly, if youāre a wolf and itās literally all town thatās not solving, itās pretty disappointing.
Youāre the literal only person whoās really engaged with my content, and Iāve been trying to engage with yours. If youāre a wolf, Iām going to be crushed. For similar reasons you just said, but also because it means your wolfrange is massively larger than Iāve ever expected.
I guess Zone acknowledged my content sometimes, but other times heās been off in his own dimension.
If my wolfrange were this large Iād be the D1 yeet in every single game after this lol
Iām just town here, though, so as much as Iād like to improve my wolfgame itās not gonna be this time
You have 1322 posts and youāre not spamming oneliners like Atlas! That would be one of the best wolfgames in this siteās history.