Everything youāve been doing so far has been ^Rand Town
Really now? If I recall correctly App was cleared for shooting Nappy in CFM2 (a game that you were a wolf in), so you should know how powerful bussing can be
I am not a damn wolf and you know it.
What? My gut was damn wrong and it has been before, but usually my gut is pretty damn good. I got no real scum pings until the whole JOAT think kind of gave me ??? pings, but I just thought it was a difference of opinion. You can note that my read slightly changed after re-reading Mole, but I wrote it off as a difference of opinion. I was wrong and town can be wrong, so you need to get your head out of the damn tunnel and find an actual wolf
This suggests you donāt think Leafia is a wolf?
If not, why donāt you find an actual wolf?
I think this is a weak argument, considering you might as well have pulled Derps/Centuries/Wazza from this. I didnāt count again and look at the interactions, but this isnāt a strong argument just for Sulit.
Vulgard had more pushers, like me, so it makes sense they werenāt night 1 kill. I still think Katze otherwise is an odd kill, but it makes sense to me that it wasnāt Vulgard.
Ok yeah.
@Vulgard
@Flameo
@SirDerpsAlotTheir WIM Dropped Significantly.
Suiltās Post Count - 183
Day 1: 106
Day 2: 63
Day 3: 14Their Day 2 Count is Half of their Day 1 Posts +10.
They havenāt really posted much this Day.
They had a giant post at start of day though. Iām not going to swap lynch based on one dead townies reads. Plus Elephas did that bolded thing for like 4/5 of Katzeās readsā¦
CallMeIo
katze:i didnt really remember too many of their posts initially so i took a reread
i dont really feel like theyāre doing anything except making their own towncore
like they feel like they just exist in thread and i donāt feel like they add very much to it
CallMeIo:However, I feel that Flameoās response was genuine. I think scum would have said it differently.
He might be scum but Iām not going to jump to any conclusions yet.
like this is a unique thought
but thereās no meat to this bone, and the conclusion is second guessing themselves
Leafia:Leafia: The hosts messed up and gave me her rolecard. Locktown.
CallMeIo:Call me Bias.
But I TR Leafia for Bolded .
this too
why do you TR leafia for a joke that isnāt that uncommon on this site
the quotes kinda broke so im quarantining them here
CallMeIo: Moleland: CallMeIo:Even though Iām Town)
[/quote]
What does this even mean?
[/quote]It means that my Rolecard is Green!
CallMeIo: Moleland: Moleland: CallMeIo:(Even though Iām Town)
[/quote]
What does this even mean?
[/quote]This comment is a āDuhā moment. Thereās no reason to add the āEven though Iām townā part of this post. Itās not like you can be friendly neutral in this game.
/Vote callmelo
[/quote]Well I didnāt want anyone to jump to any conclusions.
If I didnāt say what I said someone might misunderstand what Iām trying to say. CallMeIo: Moleland:Butā¦ Why was this comment needed?
[/quote]
Re-Quote my post and remove that comment and see for yourself.
CallMeIo: Wisp:Tempted to just policy vote Mole for 429
[/quote]
But will you?
/Vote Mole
How about now? CallMeIo: Wisp:I have a wolf PoE of like
Elephas/ Mole /Flameo, dont know if that makes sense as a team, but on an individual level they all bring posts that I hate
[/quote]I donāt mind this PoE.
Not sure on Flameo, but the other 2 seem fine. CallMeIo:Tier D - Good Chance to be Scum
Elephas
Molethe progression on moleland here feels kinda wack
as far as i can tell i quoted every post in their ISO regarding moleland
wouldnāt mind seeing this player yeeted atm
wanna hear more progression from them though
I highlighted sentences that I think are important.
Also please ignore all of the [/quote]s. I was too lazy to fix every quote individually, and if I remove a single [/quote] it destroys the post.
This is one of katzeās strongest reads, as he ended up voting on this wagon at the end of the day, and even suggested a CFD to it.
I think it is very important that we make sure this player contributes to the thread , as katze said they are simply existing, and he wants to see more progression.
If katze was not killed in a PR hunt, this is another read that could have contributed to him being selected as the nightkill.
[quote=āElephas, post:1568, topic:83078ā]
Vulgard
[quote=ākatze, post:310, topic:83078, full:trueā]
my only reservation with vulgard at the moment is
posts
Vulgard:This is the exact same reaction I got last time I correctly townread him as town, so yeah. Lock it in.
Somethingās up with kat this game, I think. Their entrance feltā¦ slow. Like they tried to settle into the thread as easily as possible (by voting sulit) instead of doing it naturally. Donāt know if it makes sense, but itās worth a vote fmpov.
/vote katze
[/quote]elaborate on this thought
[/quote] Vulgard:I no longer think that after you wrote this, so any explanation is going to be moot.
katze:what post of mine changed your mind?
Vulgard:Literally the one I responded to, I think the way youāre handling my slot is very consistent with your villagery thought process in the last FoL.
But this time, we can actually solve the game together instead of going after each other. You in?
i donāt fully understand or follow his thought process here
it doesnāt feel natural?
but the rest of his posting seems fine
iāll probably have a 100% read on vulgard by EoD anyway
katze:their posts were most likely written by a villager
thatās the easiest way to describe my read on him but i know he hates it so iāll try to explain it as best as i can
when vulgard is a villager, his posts have a certain level of genuineness that he is really not good at replicating as a wolf
his level of fake solving as a wolf is good at face value, but when you look at it under a microscope theyāre much weaker posts than when heās a villager
and his posts have not felt like his wolf posts
but generally when vulgard is a villager youāll see one post and its like
āthis post cannot ever come from wolf!Vulgardā
i have not seen that post
but i donāt hate his posts
so heās probably just town
katze:i saw him in thread and remembered that i hadnāt seen much of him for a while
like i said in my thoughts posts he didnāt have that one post that convinced me he was a villager yet
but his posting has been fine and since then (just caught up) I think heās still moderately towny
still havenāt seen the post to lock it in though
(also the wording was half a reference to a prior game)
katze:at the end of it i didnāt scumread him
i thought those specific posts were odd but i thought the rest of his posts were fine
when vulgard is a wolf i usually hate almost all of his posts, especially his entrances and when heās under pressure
katze:i just realized vulgards opening posts are selfvoting and calling himself a wolf (historically theyāre more memey as a wolf but theyāve toned their memeiness up as a villager somewhat)
and the fact theyāre still yet to write a post that never comes from wolfgard
katze:dont think iād yeet him today still
but had i seen that earlier iād probably have been more wary on him
I highlighted the sentences I see as important.
In an early post, katze said that he is fairly comfortable reading Vulgard, and likely the best in the thread at doing so. He stated that by the end of the day, he would have a ā100% read,ā yet states that Vulgard is probably a villager. This is not 100%.
I do think that if katze were killed for any of his reads, it is very likely this one.
Although he ended up townleaning Vulgard, it is quite clear that katze is good at reading this player, and if katze were not killed early, he may have called Vulgard out as scum.If katze were killed late, this read would likely be treated almost as a check upon his VT flip.
WAIT. You literally bolded that stuff yourselfā¦ this is a massive cherrypick, wouldnāt you say?
What do you think about Sulit posting about Elephas as part of their giantpost at start of day? It didnāt feel fake to me.
sulit:I really donāt like how Elphas left a vote on ash and was there for EOD but didnāt really do much afterwards, but Iāve found them towny otherwise so Iād probably save this if I ever make it to Lylo <small which is doubtful.
sulit:Elphas
I wonder if Sulit makes this giantpost mentioning Elephas in advance, while actively already knowing they are going to kill Elephas and only in unlikely situations where they would be JOAT healed, this would be of merit. Iām guessing unlikely.
Leafia: I have my reservations about this slot as it really puzzles me Her push on Gorta so early in the day seems pretty scummy to me and theyāre a known hard busser, so I can see why people would be scumreading her. Hmmm, her interaction with Mole does paint her in a good light as Mole was clearly trying to make her look scummy. Sheās been more re evaluatily and is making her own reads too, but whether thatās a sign of an improving scumgame or a towngame is hard to tell for certain. Iāll have to ISO her later to be s- wait. This is me. Oops. This is town. Iām as sure of it as I am about Vulgard being town.
guys now Iām wondering if Leafia is funnier as town or mafia to get a more solid read
Aah I wanted to say more, but late for work. I think the double ādonāt know Elephas slipā from whatever new person gives me quite a null read ultimately, will explain later bye.
This suggests you donāt think Leafia is a wolf?
I went into Leafiaās ISO with an open mind and came out with a scum read
Derps: Heās making a lot of godawful pushes and defending obvious wolves but sadly, this is town AI for him. I did read through Hell in a Cell where he was scum and this feels closer to his town games than he did there.
Wazza: Not sure how to read him right now, but giving off a slightly townie vibe currently. His reaction to my confusion regarding his slot seems townish to me as I feel scum wouldāve handled that differently.
Centuries: I donāt remember much from him so I donāt really have a good or even bad read on him, but GTH, Iād slightly townish.
PK: He replaced in for one of my towncore so now heās in my towncore in CatLoverās place.
Vulgard: My top townread and the only one that itās impossible for me to be wrong about. Clearly town.Gorta: Very clearly scum. His defense of himself at the start of D3 was godawful and included OMGUSing me and being ultra LAMIST. I honestly canāt see how anyone could possibly think heās town here. Heās virtually openwolfing here and he was even scummy before EoD1. The ones TRing him need to take a close look on his slot and re eval.
sulit: Not too sure about this slot. I remember TRing her but I canāt really recall why exactly. It doesnāt help that I keep getting her confused with Wiisp.
CallMeIo: I desperately want lo here to be town as Iād love a world where sheās town, but her reads and how sure she is of everything have me slightly doubting that such a world exists. I still TL them though although that may be due to me wanting her to be town so badly.
Elephas: Considering that theyāre a dead flipped townie, Iām equally as confident that theyāre town as I am about Vulgard being town.Leafia: I have my reservations about this slot as it really puzzles me Her push on Gorta so early in the day seems pretty scummy to me and theyāre a known hard busser, so I can see why people would be scumreading her. Hmmm, her interaction with Mole does paint her in a good light as Mole was clearly trying to make her look scummy. Sheās been more re evaluatily and is making her own reads too, but whether thatās a sign of an improving scumgame or a towngame is hard to tell for certain. Iāll have to ISO her later to be s- wait. This is me. Oops. This is town. Iām as sure of it as I am about Vulgard being town.
Moleland: Iām as sure of him being scuum as I am about Gorta being scum. Considering heās a dead flipped scum, thatās saying something.
Ash: I have no idea why people were scumreading him honestly, although he has dropped off the radar after EoD1. Considering thatās when he was yeeted though, thatās completely understandable.
Katze: Another slot I wasnāt sure about all of D1. RIP you townie you. You were an excellent cat and weāll win this for you.
Wiisp: Pretty sure this is town at the moment. Sheās had a very townie feel to her ever since the second half of D1.
Flameo: Iām slightly confident that heās town. Although if Iām misclearing scum, this slot and Wazza are the most likely candidates.
This post looks like you had to force yourself to have exactly two potential scumreads, since there are two wolves alive.
Not sure what it means for your alignment, but Iām leaning mafia.
If you suspect them, vote them with me.
Anyways just curious, havenāt read the thread yet, howās my slot looking?
Fairly strong town independently, and the flipped wolf called you scum all game.
Leafia:To save their life duh. Bussing doesnāt potentially give you as much cred as you think it does and people make dumb decisions all the time. It doesnāt mean theyāre townie.
Stop making yourself look more scummy.
Think about what your posting before you post it.
This sure is a post.
Also, noting that both sulit and Mole TRed each other for thin reasons this game at some point.
Iām in more of a sulit/Leafia/gorta headspace tbh. I keep flip-flopping on Leafia.
We need to keep in mind that Leafia is a hard busser and they started calling Mole scum at post 100 and kept focusing on them almost primarily during both days
Leafia interactions with Mole
Townreading me this early without even explaining why? Is this an attempt to pocket me?
No. Thatās not a meme.
I honestly donāt like Moleās tone right now and Elephas has improved a bit in my eyes so I think Sulit might have the right idea. Letās apply some pressure here and see what develops.
/Vote Moleland @Arete
I hate that meme because it sucks so much. Youāre the one uninterested in being very townie.
Both of those are false. Thereās never anything funny about intentionally antagonizing someone which ruins their ability to enjoy the game. Now stop it.
You overused it massively.
You should read the entire game before posting.
So you know everything that has gone on.
Skimming isnāt reading. Without reading, how do you expect to be able to solve the game?
Exactly why reading is better than skimming. If doesnāt even take very long.
Hereās my current read on Mole and why. Slight scumlean at the moment because he seems completely uninterested in solving the game and figuring out who the scum is.
No. Just you at the moment. Why would I be scumreading 12 players?
So? Most of them arenāt even here and those that are are at least reading through the game and trying to solve things. All except for you.
You literally admitted that youāre not. You literally said that you only skimmed the thread.
Thereās value in looking at all posts.
Calling it now for postgame cred. Scumteam is Mole, Centuries, and Wiisp. Honestly though, Iāll be pretty pleasantly surprised if Iām correct here.
They also agree with Mole on certain things despite heavily scum reading them on the anti town JOAT cover
Thatās actually a good idea I think.
Leafiaās d3 posting has been awful as well
Leafia d3 posts that ping me
I feel bad for ever doubting Elephas for a second now and I told everyone that Mole was scum. It seems my first assessment of him antagonizing me to try to make me look scummy was right. So, he has nothing really to apologize for. He was just trying to make me look scummy so town wouldnāt trust me, so he didnāt do anything wrong. He was just trying to win, so I guess we can be friends Mole. Youāre not as bad as I thought you were.
This paints Gorta in a terrible light too, as he was hard defending Mole for no real reason EoD2. I personally think that Derps was just misguided. Him being a wolf isnāt impossible though.
As for Derps saying that Gorta is very likely a villager, Iām placing the same amount of trust in that that I placed in him saying that Mole is a villager at EoD 2. While I do think heās town, I trust his judgement on who scum and town are even less than I could throw an Elephant.
Yeah, Iām a big busser, although in the one scumgame I had with Mole as a teammate, we were at each otherās throats the entire time he was alive.
I agree completely with this. That and trying to make me look scummy in the process. He said it surprised him that I didnāt get all defensive and LAMIST, and I believe him when he says that. He expected me to go all LAMIST and probably wanted me to be theD1 misyeet.
Iām going to listen to and trust Elephas. Vulgard is a villager.
I think you get almost as much as I do honestly considering I was hard going after Mole near the end of both days and I was the first to call out Mole for being wolfy.
That being said, another thing that needs to be done today I think is resolving Gortaās slot.
/vote Gorta @Arete
I doubt Iāll change this vote at all today, unless Gorta improves massively. Right now, Iām 85% sure that Gorta is a wolf as well, and considering at EoD 2 I was 95% sure that Mole was a wolf, thatās saying a lot.There was a small part of my brain saying What if Iām wrong and Mole is town? that was only silenced upon seeing his flip, which was definitely a relief to me admittedly. EoD2 was stressful, but in the end, we yeeted a wolf.
Iām not saying I should be completely clear due to it and thereās nothing BS about my accusation and I think that you know it. What youāre doing now is just making me suspect you even more.
Iāll admit that if I was a wolf and you were a town in this situation, what Iām doing now is exactly what I would do, but the reverse is also true. You need to take other things into consideration while trying to solve my slot, like how Mole acted towards me among other things. If you take just one thing as proof of someoneā;s alignment, youāre just asking to towncore a wolf or misyeet a town. You need to look at the whole picture.
If I was someone else who knew my playstyle as well as I do, Iād be reading myself as a townlean currently. Could still be a wolf but is slightly more likely to be a villager. Iām guessing the uninformed spec chat reads me as close to that, although I can see how someone could scumlean me even now, as I have done at least a few scummy things.
Plus, you never explained why you hard defended Mole, who happened to be scum. Thatās what a villager wouldāve done I think. A villager would understand me scumreading them after how you hard defended Mole.
Iā,m honestly surprised that Ele was the N2 kill and I think I know why the wolves killed him too. In the hopes of making Vulgard look bad. They saw that Ele trusted Vulgard completely and knew that they had to die. They were also likely worried that Elephas would be townreading me after Moleās flip, which I doubt is something the wolves want.
Trust me when I say this fellow townies, but thereā;s absolutely no world where Elephas dies N2 that has Vulgard as a wolf. If Vulgard was a wolf, then Elephas would be alive right now. Vulgard is as locked town as hewād be if he was a revealed IC in my eyes right now.
Right now, Gorta is TMIing me as town I think.
Hereās my new and improved readslist.
an_gorta_pratai
VVV
Leafia
Vulgard
DerpsVV
Wiisp
Sulit
CallmeloV
Flameo
W
Centuries
WazzaWW
Gorta
PoE being
Gorta/Wazza/Centuries/Flameo
I honestly hate how few scumreads I have as it means at least one if not both of the wolves are being miscleared by me. Flameo is the one Iām most likely to be wrong about honestly.
Derps: Heās making a lot of godawful pushes and defending obvious wolves but sadly, this is town AI for him. I did read through Hell in a Cell where he was scum and this feels closer to his town games than he did there.
Wazza: Not sure how to read him right now, but giving off a slightly townie vibe currently. His reaction to my confusion regarding his slot seems townish to me as I feel scum wouldāve handled that differently.
Centuries: I donāt remember much from him so I donāt really have a good or even bad read on him, but GTH, Iād slightly townish.
PK: He replaced in for one of my towncore so now heās in my towncore in CatLoverās place.
Vulgard: My top townread and the only one that itās impossible for me to be wrong about. Clearly town.Gorta: Very clearly scum. His defense of himself at the start of D3 was godawful and included OMGUSing me and being ultra LAMIST. I honestly canāt see how anyone could possibly think heās town here. Heās virtually openwolfing here and he was even scummy before EoD1. The ones TRing him need to take a close look on his slot and re eval.
sulit: Not too sure about this slot. I remember TRing her but I canāt really recall why exactly. It doesnāt help that I keep getting her confused with Wiisp.
CallMeIo: I desperately want lo here to be town as Iād love a world where sheās town, but her reads and how sure she is of everything have me slightly doubting that such a world exists. I still TL them though although that may be due to me wanting her to be town so badly.
Elephas: Considering that theyāre a dead flipped townie, Iām equally as confident that theyāre town as I am about Vulgard being town.Leafia: I have my reservations about this slot as it really puzzles me Her push on Gorta so early in the day seems pretty scummy to me and theyāre a known hard busser, so I can see why people would be scumreading her. Hmmm, her interaction with Mole does paint her in a good light as Mole was clearly trying to make her look scummy. Sheās been more re evaluatily and is making her own reads too, but whether thatās a sign of an improving scumgame or a towngame is hard to tell for certain. Iāll have to ISO her later to be s- wait. This is me. Oops. This is town. Iām as sure of it as I am about Vulgard being town.
Moleland: Iām as sure of him being scuum as I am about Gorta being scum. Considering heās a dead flipped scum, thatās saying something.
Ash: I have no idea why people were scumreading him honestly, although he has dropped off the radar after EoD1. Considering thatās when he was yeeted though, thatās completely understandable.
Katze: Another slot I wasnāt sure about all of D1. RIP you townie you. You were an excellent cat and weāll win this for you.
Wiisp: Pretty sure this is town at the moment. Sheās had a very townie feel to her ever since the second half of D1.
Flameo: Iām slightly confident that heās town. Although if Iām misclearing scum, this slot and Wazza are the most likely candidates.
Right out of the gate Leafia keeps bringing up things about being on Molesās case since d1, admits thats what she would do as a wolf and pushes me without considering a world in which I am town. I didnāt start to think that Leafia was a wolf until I saw her d3 posts
Iām in more of a sulit/Leafia/gorta headspace tbh. I keep flip-flopping on Leafia.
From Katzeās reads and Leafiaās actions I think it could be Leafia/Mole/Sulit
I feel like the two of you shouldnāt thunderdome yourselves and should evaluate other players, too.
Right now, Iām convinced we have a winning PoE and thereās no reason to think we donāt considering the flips have been proving me right so far. So maybe yeeting sulit/gorta/Leafia in any order = we just win?
I kinda feel like Leafia being very inflexible here is town indicative for her, though, because sheās limiting her wolf options to push people. Sheās just pushing one person and if gortaās town, his flip makes her look bad.
On the other hand, gorta has only managed to level up when he is a solid yeet candidate. He was one on day 1, too, but ash wagon had advantage over his.
I donāt like the fact my towncore members keep getting replaced, but weāll just have to work from the established consensus. We did get a wolf by going that way, so itās probably safe to keep going until we happen to misyeet villagers again.
I would say 75% of Leafiaās d1 and d2 posts this game have been focused on Mole, which is the trademark of a bus in my opinion. Ans was also the first to āsuspectā CRich in SFoL 61.5 and I think the same thing could be happening here
I kinda feel like Leafia being very inflexible here is town indicative for her, though, because sheās limiting her wolf options to push people. Sheās just pushing one person and if gortaās town, his flip makes her look bad.
On the other hand, gorta has only managed to level up when he is a solid yeet candidate. He was one on day 1, too, but ash wagon had advantage over his.
At this point there are arguments against both of you, and taking you both to YeetLo is going to end poorly, so Iād rather remove at least one of you from the game beforehand.
Yeeting Leafia is going to make me feel bad if sheās town, and the same applies to gorta, but we gotta do what we gotta do, right?
I need a VC before I make any further decisions.
Vote Count
Vote Target | Voted by | Votes |
---|---|---|
an_gorta_pratai | Leafia, Intensify, Flameo | 3/6 |
Flameo | SirDerpsAlot | 1/6 |
Leafia | Wazza | 1/6 |
sulit | CallMeIo | 1/6 |