Jeremy
Geyde/luxy
Priestess/you
i posted my reasoning in my wallpost
Since Jeremy is a first-timer I think it is valid unless it is a you+Jeremy scumteam and you planned that on purpose. I believe scum!Jeremy alone would have let it slip.
Honestly both scum and town alike, by perceiving that, could see it was a trap of sorts. I’m not bought.
I had a tinfoil that there was one hydra at town and other at scumteam but if you asked for it specifically then it’s ok
but he wasn’t calling it ingenuine because he read it as a trap. he called it ingenuine because he thought i was high on ketamine(don’t ask).
so he had the right read but for the wrong reason here.
I still see it as townie progression because he defenitely sensed i was being fake but also didn’t inheretly think it was some kind of grand reactiontest and so i don’t think w!geyde ever comes up with and posts that post. it comes from v!geyde a lot more often IMO
Here are my reads pre-Marshal’s out:
Chloe and priestess not same scumteam
Leaning scum on Marshal
Priestess seems mildly towny
Leaning scum on mist, done nothing but fluff upon entry
Jeremy v
Isaac w
Chloe seems super pure upon looking at it tbh
Isaac wolf has some credit
Jeremy seems to be happy doing his own thing to me whereas Isaac seems to be backing up and supporting jeremy and has less originality. It’s a distinct possibility that isaac is trying to pocket his brother
I mean that was before my out in which i tried to look scummy so i don’t blame the read.
but i’ll let luxy explain his reasoning if he wishes
Real take
I took ketamine as an answer because I didn’t feel like you would normally do that as either alignment