I don’t think scum!Vul admits to this so blatantly.
Incorrect read, but incorrect in a very towny way from my perspective.
Arete is town. Next. 
Basically
The fire the interaction had was gone when me and Ici went off it for the most part
Now it still occupies thread’s focus despite one of the parties mostly dissolving
Yet it still takes all of thread
Wolf is in it
Eevee is most likely wolf ergo since obv
And?
That’s not the, answer, look:
I see you used “accusser” in both cases.
Why are you telling me first you don’t scumread all your accusers and can’t name a single person right afterwards?
Anyway, like I was saying, I think this post contains some good clues towards Arete’s allignment, since it’s analytical, reasonably lengthy, and has some good points.
I think they’re a villager, and not just becaue their assessment of Maxi soft-mindmelds mine (although yes, it’s that, definitely). What I quite like about this post is that they’re being critical of the points surrounding Maxi in an analytical way while nonetheless agreeing with them. That indicates that they can analyse points and agree or disagree with them, wheras a wolf would simplistically agree with anybody who supports their agenda.
Long story short, post villagery lul
Excuse me, look at people sheeping me, rather than on person who started it.
Nothing which Vulgard said so far convinced me to stop pushing my own read.
1 Like
That’s not what I’m arguing
It’s entirely disengaged with your actual points or who led what
You are saying that thread is focused on Vulgard.
That’s wrong.
You and Ici joined on my push and then hopped of.
Thread is not focused on Vulgard. I am.
And I’m gonna keep going, considering that all his posts so far were pretty much contradictions and made stuff made just to look better in eyes of other players.
1 Like
I’ve been skimming and agree with eevee here.
Vulgard is acting like his lotrfm scum game.
And has said many things that I did as scum when pushed hard in SFoL 53.
“Everyone on my wagon is scum”
“Hmm things you are saying are pretty convenient”
Sigh. Why am I coming back to this.
What do you actually want to hear from me? Of course I’m going to be contradictory. I’ve never been good at logic, I’m trying to be better but it’s clearly not working if it’s being called terrible all over.
What am I supposed to say here?
I disagree strongly with this to the point that I have no idea how you even came to that conclusion.
if this is the case then i don’t think any of the ppl he pushed r scum
however, i do agree with that as he has a post full of scumreads and not much else
He is going full argumentative and contradictory.
Widely scumread d1, too.
And someone hard defends him. But In this case it is kai and not me
don’t think kai is scum tbh
just feel like they would’ve been acting differently by now or something
gutread ig
I still think there is scum in Geyde/Eevee/Ici/Max. There just has to be. Might be two scum.
Basically I think it’s half-and-half town/scum, not everyone scum anymore. Of course, I was confirmation biased before. It can’t be that bad.
My eyes are on Eevee because his look on the game has been extremely narrow and everything he has done was push me. Nothing else.
I don’t like the fact Geyde seems to be controlling the thread, which is what pings me the most, and kinda disregarding me as the ‘AtE slot’, as something that ‘should be left alone.’ It’s like he is like ‘whatever this is mislynchable later carry on.’
Ici is probably the most likely from among my voters to be town because he doesn’t feel like an agenda pusher to me. I can’t really explain this well. Yeah, I know, Vul logic bad. I just get the least pinged by Ici out of the three.