Arctic, I very clearly said what my conclusion is.
After all, did I not say who my weakest person in the PoE is?
from what youāve said i donāt understand how you think pandas is more likely to be a wolf than eli
I feel like Iām giving pandas a newbie card when I shouldnāt be and itās causing me to read them more harshly tbh.
evil why
I feel like CCing the very likely parity cop isnāt exactly trying to do whatās right
yep
trying to figure out why windward was killed, and iām pretty sure itās borderline clearing for nuclear
out of me, gghana and wind she was the most willing to see nuclear as a villager
aside from this and seeing nuclear more likely to be a villager, windās reads didnāt differ that much from mine and gghanaās
so if this is the main difference, this heavily incriminates pkr and cloned because she was the most willing to look outside of the current poe and she was nightkilled
waitā¦
didnāt sulit also scumread cloned
meh, sulit was the most obvious villager so iām not sure how valid that approach is
although you could make an argument for gghana being slightly more obvious
this was windās early poe
by the way
someone might say it feels like iām cherrypicking what fits with my world
i am cherrypicking, but this isnāt the criteria for what iām choosing - iām choosing windās reads that were different from mine and/or gghanaās because these are the reasons she was nightkilled over us
this was aelinās PoE
ā¦holy shit
oh yeah
this reminds me
PKRās villa read on nightingale was absolutely horrific and with basically no valid explanation it looks like pure TMI, iāll find it after this
oh wait
i had the same read and completely forgot about this lmao
yuh oh
looks bad for pkr/cloned and good for nuclear
this is the only thing giving me pause
but all the other evidence canāt really be ignored, especially since the main thing here is that wind was going to read over pkr and cloned overnight ā which wolves clearly did not want happening
wolves also didnāt want us reconsidering nuclear? interesting
wind kept expressing how much she wanted to look into cloned and PKR and how she thought our current PoE only contained 1-2 wolves (which seems to be correct with my world now)
her interest in figuring out these slots is the biggest difference between her and me/gghana
if wolves didnāt want to wind to figure out these slots, then itās likely they were happy with what they were being read as, which funnily enough, was v
now why would wolves want to keep villagers being read as villagers?
spoiler: they arenāt villagers
TL;DR wind was killed because she was going to look into cloned and PKR, who were currently being read as villagers
wolves would only want to stop wind re-evaluating these reads if they were incorrect - which heavily incriminates pkr and cloned
Good morning peoples
ā¦arctic youāre just wrong here
What kind of wolf goes in and kills the slot that would be most incriminating for them
Frankly it speaks in the opposite direction, since the nka would generate similar lines of thinking as you are having rn and misexe in LyLo
Errrā¦ I think it looks bad for Cloned.
But how does this look bad for me?
I explained itā¦
I noticed from re-reading thing game that PKR struggles with TMI as a wolf ā for instance he was insistent that the N1 kill was a jump (which it was) and a lot of his villa reads look like they were either entirely fake or taken from a list of things which are seen as normally villagery without any nuance
His early townread on sam and whysper is well within this realm of TMI, especially since i feel like the former was incredibly misplaced
This conviction in trying to shut down a townread on sam does not feel natural, especially since he had hardly given any content and people werenāt sure on his alignment
i thought this was villagery
then i thought about it for 5 more seconds and realize itās an incredibly odd thing for a villager to say
especially since if heās a wolf, this was probably the exact scenario (and hence fits in with his handling of TMI)
this looks suuuuper bad in hindsight and iām sticking with my v!night w!pkr read because holy fuck
plus all of this conviction is never actually followed with a vote on anyone?
the read has 0 progression, 0 explanation yet massive conviction and no attempt to stop nightingale dying at eod? yeah, thatās TMI
godfather:tm:
hereās my favourite part of this ISO where pkr, a theoretical villager, is upset about being read as pack wolf but not lw
yeah, because a villager really cares about which wolf role theyāre being read as
no, it looks like packwolf mad theyāve been caught since a free win in lylo was going to be given to pkr if lost wolf flipped before him
this was PKRās read on nuclear
what
pkr pushing sam for being inactive here is pretty hypocritical considering he shut down someone else reading him for inactivity
uh
wait what
how does nuclear being read as ānot w/w with pkrā clear him if pkr is also a villager from his pov?
this is TMIāing nuclear v and also slipping
āthis person whose alignment i theoretically donāt know is doing a scummy thingā
āyeah theyāre still townā
why the hell would there be 1 wolf between gghana and cloned
what kind of read is this
iām pretty sure this is just TMIāing cloned w if pkr is a wolf
āthe poe has been wrong and we keep killing villagers in itā
town: changes the poe
āwe canāt just keep going through the poe!!!ā
pkrās ate loses any credit because of this one embedded part
can i point out that pkrās perspective on sam and red_pandas makes no sense
he goes back and forth between saying sam is wolfy for being new, but then saying heās not actually new, and then says red_pandas is new but itās fine because they just ādonāt know the ways of FMā
if my world is wrong itās probably on this slot, but i still think iām right
the only thing that looks vaguely good is the ATE which we know for PKR isnāt valid
the way heās handled leafia and nightingale (especially nightingale) iāve decided looks pretty horrendous
(forgot to include this part but PKR TMIāed whysper as pack wolf lmao)
1 Like
the point was sheās going to look at your slots overnight to get a better conclusion on them
but yeah, she did say she wasnāt convinced you were a wolf so i guess that post does make you look better
this was your explanation
and itās absolutely horrendous
vibes? agreeing on stuff?
this level of reasoning does not correlate with your confidence on night being a villager which is why it looks like TMI
wolves have to weigh up whether they want to deal with people finding out they are incriminated by the night kill or whether they want to deal with having wind alive coming in guns blazing
i think itās pretty obvious they would rather deal with the first