Experience with playing with Jane, ye?
Then why wasnât the wierd hypocrisy at eod scummy to you?
I dont think that is wolfy and it didnât factor in to my reads so 
not saying it was bad to wolf read jane, Iâm saying acting on it with the shot against the direct wishes of many people was not good
Fair.
I stopped listening to people who doubted my HS claim, and they also stopped engaging with me.
Pretty sure had I remained open minded, I would have doubted the shot enough to not take it.
Iâd have no defence to âWahah, you made us waste day 2â but it isnât entirely my fault Whysp lived until Mylo.
entirely? no
but you coulda just yeeted it
but i get it
lessons lessons
being a PR is stressful
ayaya
1 Like
The quality of townâs play after you died doesnât change the quality of your own play.
Even if jane was wolf I think it would be a bad play.
Itâs like if my dad was like âWell son, I gambled your college savings and I doubled the money!â
Iâm not gonna be pissed but that doesnât change that gambling my college savings is a dumb idea
and if he went âWell son, I gambled your college savings and I lost all of itâ even thought I specifically told him just to not touch it iâd be rightfully mad
you took a gamble you should not have and lost, even if I flunked out of college doesnât change that you should not have gambled my savings
even if you doubled the money doesnât change that you should not have done it
this isnât comparative, it was not a good idea regardless of the eventual outcome, and this conversation is no longer productive so im just going to not
3 Likes
Fair. But I didnât see it as a gamble since I thought even if I was wrong, at the end of day 2 the game state was the same.
I havenât had a chance to go through all the chat yet. I skimmed through but want to read again. Many of you have much kinder words than I was expecting. It truly makes me want to cry. 
I have apologies as well for my part in making things go off the rails for town. I kept wondering whether it would have been better in the long run for me to try to get MLâd so I didnât draw so much attention away from the real wolves. From hindsight, perhaps it would have been since I was a constant wagon and the final ML. But as far as gameplay, I donât think we want to encourage people to just give up when they are targeted.
I think I saw Apprentice or Geyde or perhaps both suggest something about how we need to better calibrate our reads based on player personalities. This is definitely something I am behind. I think this would make reads much better. Iâm toying with the idea of developing a personality type list similar to Myer-Briggs or the Big Five.
I hope there are no hard feelings. I donât hold any grudges. I completely understand how each player reacted based on their playstyle and view of how the game should be played even if I donât entirely agree with their mindsets. And I honestly wasnât trying to start deep wolf hunting nor going against the top tier players or whatever. Iâm sorry it ended up that way.
Okay, stopping here since this is already bordering on becoming a wallpost. 
12 Likes
no one is mad at you Whysper
frankly the extent to which you continued posting and solving, even under pressure, is commendable 
9 Likes
whysper shush now
you did so well considering this was only your fourth game and i for one would have just frozen and let others do the decision making for me. but you kept putting in effort and didnât give up. youâve proven yourself to be a good player already but even i understand why youâd want to take a break for awhile now and i donât blame you for it.
long story short go whysper! also please adopt me
2 Likes
Yeah, I think a short break will be good. I also want to get back to practicing reads and evaluate my games. I was suppose to continue that with Geyde but never did since I spent all my available time on the games. Itâs too hard to do both at the same time, so I need to focus on the practice/improvement for now.
Haha, Iâd love to adopt you. My two nieces, whom I treat like daughters, are only like a few years younger than you. 
They would love you as a big sister.
5 Likes