Weekly Monday Discussion #5 - Alts & Awards!

[Vulgard]

but my argument is that the concept of alts isn’t at fault

[sulit]

Maybe some kind of alt ban if they are obvious or something
Idk

[MaximusPrime]

idk much about other peoples’ alts but i think my alt games were pretty fun ig

[orangeandblack5]

no

nonono

that’s

really

really hard to actually make work

[Geyde]

@Chloe

Also, before I go

Should alt mods be more strict on who can and can’t alt? Should we wotm people who we have reason to believe will simply gimmick, or be extremely obvious on an alt?

okay now i go

I would say yes, in order to prevent people I don’t like from alting

[Vulgard]

i honestly have the same stance on both issues discussed today

good concept
used poorly by the playerbase

[Vulgard]

which is why i don’t support removing either (because the concept isn’t inherently flawed) but i also understand why people want it removed

[Geyde]

Vulgard’s reads

@Vulgard

good concept
used poorly by the playerbase

[Emilia]

gimmick alt is bad why?

[Vulgard]

because nobody wants to read a roleplayer in a mafia game 90% of the time
you’d need a game full of roleplayers for that to be normal and expected

[sulit]

town play

@Vulgard

good concept
used poorly by the playerbase

[Vulgard]

@Vulgard

because nobody wants to read a roleplayer in a mafia game 90% of the time
you’d need a game full of roleplayers for that to be normal and expected

like
if you want gimmick alts then i unironically believe a roleplay anonymous fm would be fun
but in normal games it makes the game harder

[Arete]

making reads

@Vulgard

good concept
used poorly by the playerbase

[Geyde]

@Vulgard

because nobody wants to read a roleplayer in a mafia game 90% of the time
you’d need a game full of roleplayers for that to be normal and expected

we all roleplay trying to be good at fm
I don’t know what you’re talking about

[Emilia]

@Vulgard

because nobody wants to read a roleplayer in a mafia game 90% of the time
you’d need a game full of roleplayers for that to be normal and expected

so u put ban on roleplaying too much

u can roleplay without alt

[sulit]

Because most of their posts are meant to be fake or copying something and it’s a pain in the ass to try to read the game with it let alone try to read them

[Geyde]

Joat^2

@Vulgard

good concept
used poorly by the playerbase

[Vulgard]

like
i’ve seen a game where a mafia member roleplayed all game and they endgamed because nobody wanted to case them really
for the entire game

[sulit]

if someone role plays without an alt im lynching them

[DatBird]

Would changing the current award system to not be best scum team player or best town player but more to best Scum/Neut/NK player and best town player work better? essentially mvp of both sides instead of Team Play

Or just a poll for top two players each game regardless of allignment. As theres not always a good scum player or good town player?