He absolutely does.
You know what would be a better idea.
Take physician, remove the day ability and replace it with 4 shots of night immunity, and give it the power to kill 2 people.
Thatās a weakness, not counterplay. Thereās no way to counter execute.
That can happen to any class. And thatās another weakness, not a counterplay.
Thatās a bad argument. A lot of classes havenāt been changed yet, but that doesnāt mean that theyāre balanced.
Because butler is weak compared to the other BD offensive drunk
Nerfing him is not a good idea
1 Like
Oh butler needs a secondary ability to give him more power definately. He doesnāt need a bulletproof which confirms him tho lol.
Saying āx class would be weak without x abilityā is not a defense because obviously any bad abilities wouldnāt just be removed theyād be replaced.
1 Like
The ability makes him better for Unseen and also lets him play more aggressively than drunk. It impacts his optimal play style in a good way.
You canāt just compare him to drunk to justify balance, you have to look at the game as a whole. I see a lot of people comparing drunk and butter and while itās true that drunk is stronger it doesnāt justify giving a roleblocker basically impenetrable bullet proof vests. It reduces the importance of protectives and make protection chains too viable. It justifies lazy play from BD as the need to work together is diminished when blockers can self protect. There needs to be some classes that are killable easily - not every class can be a one man army.
I donāt hate it, but butler definately doesnāt need it.
1 Like
Just remove all BD,Evil and Neutral classes and turn them into Civilians and Goons, this is balanced.
Happy hour and concentrated wine could be swapped.
Swap happy hour and party.
1 Like
Every class doesnāt need a defensive ability.