reasons to call them town
you don’t have to post full-fledged reads
just thoughts
if my initial take on intensify was correct and he’s been his tmi-less villagery self all this time i’m going to be annoyed
actually no
/vote Apprentice change of plans
i think they’re one of the slots i have the fewest reasons to townread
ash
I don’t remember much about this one, but I do remember getting some off feelings from Ash early on. I also got off feelings from Ash in JOAT2, so I will get to this one eventually.
luxy
I think Luxy is most likely town based off of their interactions with Leafia, as I don’t think they would be familiar with that slot and thus most of the common just Leafia things 
they wouldn’t know about. This could be a bad way to read them, but I am trying to explain town pings.
wazza
after my last game with Wazza I don’t know how to feel about them
intensify
Intensify is known for being wolfy and I still have to read the game Intensify subbed into, but I don’t see much reason to think they are town. I guess it’s possible he is town, but I don’t know
sulit
I don’t think I have ever seen scum Sulit and wouldn’t know how scum Sulit plays, but people say her scum tell is going from high energy to slanking. The only hangup I have on that tell is that Sulit was similar in SFoL 63
whysper
Whysper this game and Whysper in SFoL 63 are so damn similar, which is why I think it’s town Whysper here
eevee
I don’t know how to read Eevee and barely remember their posts
appel
Appel is the same as Eevee in my opinion
apprentice
Now, I think this could be a wolf here. Apprentice is known for bussing and shooting a scum mate isn’t out of their scum range.
I still need to case people to get a better reads, but those are my initial thoughts on that list
ash - helping to solve
luxy - helping to solve
wazza - seems like frustrated town
gorta - tone feels same as SFoL63
intensify - can’t say much other than possibly confused town
sulit - early tone good
whysper - me trying the best I can to solve
eevee - started to interact more compared to previous player in slot
appel - originally seemed very pro-town
apprentice - possibly frustrated town, appears really convinced he found Seth as wolf and should get credit
i asked for reasons to call them town not scum
bruh
okay um
i think you’re tired because this isn’t what i requested at all
then just say so in the list instead of explaining why they are wolves
it makes the exercise pointless
the idea is to figure out which players might be miscleared
I didn’t try to screw that up, but I wasn’t sure what to say and just gave my thoughts
We’re both in PoE. Why wouldn’t you consider it being wolf theatre? Zzz
I haven’t focused on Wazza until today, but I did point out my dislike towards his slot even D1
i’m just gonna do the inverse of that exercise for myself
centuries - doesn’t seem to care about gamestate, possibly bussed mole when he was going to die anyway
ash4fun - his posts have been conventionally villagery, but he seems to lack the engagement many flipped villagers had and he has been mostly on the sidelines whenever an argument popped up, indicating wolf tmi on villagers squabbling
trochidillae - hasn’t done much to move the game in either direction, following consensus most of the time
an_gorta_pratai - seems to have issues with catching up and offering reads, could be a wolf playing catchup to stay utr, has also had garbage scumreads so far but that’s not exclusive to him in any way
intensify - weird hedge on flipped wolf seth, looks bad by association with him, has also been very hesitant to shoot today and wanted the village to guide his shot
light - posts generally have little substance and a lot of fluff in a gamestate with tons of flipped villas
wazza - doing his own thing when we need to organize ourselves, aggression seems misplaced and not really going anywhere, mostly detached from the main discussion, possibly indicating tmi on villagers squabbling
luxy - aggressively pushed and shot a villager, aggression turned the thread into a tvt arguing mess for a while, doesn’t seem to be able to re-evaluate despite us only killing 2/6 wolves so far
universal - iso isn’t very impressive overall, pure tone is all the slot has, but i think they can have that as a wolf as well
thunal33 - no posts are very impressive by themselves, shot on mole could be construed as a bus shot, has been disengaged from the main arguments in the thread which we know to have been tvt, possibly indicating wolf tmi on villagers squabbling
sulit - has really dropped off after day 1, tonally good originally but falling off a cliff, does not interact with anyone now; lack of investment in the ita phase is possibly villagery given how the phase went, but the lack of presence is still meh
whysper - unimpressive iso with low postcount, posts don’t really move the thread either way, has no pull and seems content with not being listened to, possibly wolf blending in
eevee - shitposting a lot in the previous slot, current slot hasn’t been overtly towny
appelsiini - has been handling the ita phase in a way that could suggest tmi, with reactions to every villager flip that could come from a wolf going “aw a villager got shot too bad”
apprentice - his play at sod2 was tantamount to “selfvote and ate,” wanted to be killed and to shoot a villager while going down, day 1 early vote and a few posts about seth are possibly bus indicative
doing this helped me solidify a few things:
- i don’t have good reasons to call whysper a wolf, and same with eevee. i think they might be villa
- my reasons for calling centuries, trochi, light and, surprisingly, intensify wolves are meh. they could all be villagers too
- ash, wazza and thunal have one thing in common; from what i could tell, they were noticably more controlled and less emotion-driven during the ita phase than many of the flipped villagers and consensus villagers. considering the flips were almost exclusively village, this could point to them being wolves. appelsiini is almost there but i have a few more reservations about her.
- reasons to call universal and sulit town seem weaker than the reasons to call them scum from my perspective. i should put them in my poe for that reason.
1 Like
i am kicking wazza, ash, and thunal out of my village reads
i am putting whysper, eevee, and intensify in my village reads (intensify is rather tentative but yeah)
i am putting universal and sulit in poe until further notice
Which slots should I look at in the current PoE? I don’t need direction, but I honestly don’t know who is left in the consensus PoE
