Wild West FM - Day 5 - Mafia Win!

[deadbananas0]

Hey Ash! Didn’t see you were in this game. Theres actually more people I know here than I thought! Yah I pretended to be your back up in PMFM, I think you were on my first game ever back on CD too.

Yah I just moved into my res hall as well. Got a class in a bit, but i’ll probably be boring and I’ll end up reading the thread

[Thunal33]

How do you quote a post other than replying to it?

[Mistyx]

oh yeah we have most of the PMFM squad here huh

[Mistyx]

highlight the text you want to quote then hit quote

[Insanity]

Apologies, a little bit sleepy right now.

Target	Votes	Voters
Surge	4/13	Vulgard, PokemonKidRyan, Apprentice, Moleland
Vulgard	1/13	Luxy
Moleland	1/13	Mist1422
Mist1422	1/13	Surge
Whysper	1/13	Sulit
Luxy	1/13	Leafia
Geyde	1/13	Geyde
PKR	1/13	Thunal33
Not Voting	15	Centuries, Clonedcheese, ash4fun, Trochidillae, an_gorta_pratai, Intensify, RangerCecil, Light, Wazza, Universal, yee-claw, Whysper, deadbananas0, Appelsiini

[Appelsiini]

Compare his wolfgame

@Vulgard

…I get weird energies from this post. But I got weird energies from AT all game when they last FoLed, and they were town, so tentative townlean.

@Vulgard

My certified First Post Read ™ would tell me Chloe is town, but the read will never work again because Chloe realizes it’s a tell of hers now.

@Vulgard

That’s not what my read was. Villagery post, though.

@Vulgard

This is going to be another one of those games where TBE posts completely normally all game and everyone still scumreads him for nothing.

Soul is a villager.

@Vulgard

This looks really forced.

@Vulgard

I think these two posts from Chloe are super towny.

@Vulgard

Centuries and Chloe are V.

@Vulgard

Soul is unfortunately a villager for scumclaiming, asking people to vote him, and then openly claiming an omgus. When he wolfs, he just goes aggro on everyone who suspects him and complains about everything in the world.

Never saw him do the thing he’s doing here as wolf. Somebody should correct me if they did.

AT lean town because I think I would get different early impressions from the slot if it did rand wolf.

Leafia already accusing someone of TMI hyper early is scummy, especially for her. She loves preflips as scum and the way she said it about TBE felt forced.

to this one

@Vulgard

gut says this is >rand v because a wolf would be thinking about how to blend in here instead of thinking about getting people into the thread
especially since a wolf can just ping people in wolfchat or something
thin read but i kinda believe this

@Vulgard

seth is a wolf
easy day 1 kill
you can start bussing him now

@Vulgard

because you’re doing that thing where you react to votes on you with encouraging words as if you want to be yeeted and you do that as a wolf because you’re aware of your red alignment

@Vulgard

your posts don’t have your towny tunnely / aggressive spark behind them so far

@Vulgard

the problem with your post is that you’re not making an alignment read on me
but you’re already suggesting that:

1. i won’t live long if i’m town
2. i should be killed by town if i do live long

and i find it baffling, because you’re doing that instead of trying to get my alignment
narratives > alignment read

@Vulgard

can you slow down with these posts holy hell
leafia is an incredibly stubborn villager, that’s my take right now
i don’t think a wolf’s first moves in the thread consist of getting into a dumb argument with someone over how to play mafia and suspecting them for scumreading someone else
it’s “too dumb to be a wolf”
TDTBW
copyrighted term, don’t use it

basically, i don’t think that wolf!leafia would start off the game by getting into an argument with luxy, arguably one of the strongest villagers here despite his break, and mindlessly pursue the read when the only basis for it is that he found sulit wolfy

i think wolf leafia would have more self-awareness than that

@Vulgard

geyde’s solving bothers me a lot
it feels like he’s been taking a sideline, critical approach of people’s play rather than getting more involved
i find that wolfy

@Vulgard

i’m struggling to figure out if apprentice is indirectly sheeping me or whether it’s a late mindmeld

The difference with his reads and the way he accuses people is huge.

[Trochilidae]

my name is spelled wrong in the vote count reeeee
i picked a complicated user though can’t say i blame ya

[Mistyx]

yee’s still typing

[Thunal33]

@Appelsiini

Compare his wolfgame

@Vulgard

…I get weird energies from this post. But I got weird energies from AT all game when they last FoLed, and they were town, so tentative townlean.

@Vulgard

My certified First Post Read ™ would tell me Chloe is town, but the read will never work again because Chloe realizes it’s a tell of hers now.

@Vulgard

That’s not what my read was. Villagery post, though.

@Vulgard

This is going to be another one of those games where TBE posts completely normally all game and everyone still scumreads him for nothing.

Soul is a villager.

@Vulgard

This looks really forced.

@Vulgard

I think these two posts from Chloe are super towny.

@Vulgard

Centuries and Chloe are V.

@Vulgard

Soul is unfortunately a villager for scumclaiming, asking people to vote him, and then openly claiming an omgus. When he wolfs, he just goes aggro on everyone who suspects him and complains about everything in the world.

Never saw him do the thing he’s doing here as wolf. Somebody should correct me if they did.

AT lean town because I think I would get different early impressions from the slot if it did rand wolf.

Leafia already accusing someone of TMI hyper early is scummy, especially for her. She loves preflips as scum and the way she said it about TBE felt forced.

to this one

@Vulgard

gut says this is >rand v because a wolf would be thinking about how to blend in here instead of thinking about getting people into the thread

especially since a wolf can just ping people in wolfchat or something
thin read but i kinda believe this

@Vulgard

seth is a wolf

easy day 1 kill
you can start bussing him now

@Vulgard

because you’re doing that thing where you react to votes on you with encouraging words as if you want to be yeeted and you do that as a wolf because you’re aware of your red alignment

@Vulgard

your posts don’t have your towny tunnely / aggressive spark behind them so far

@Vulgard

the problem with your post is that you’re not making an alignment read on me

but you’re already suggesting that:

1. i won’t live long if i’m town
2. i should be killed by town if i do live long

and i find it baffling, because you’re doing that instead of trying to get my alignment
narratives > alignment read

@Vulgard

can you slow down with these posts holy hell

leafia is an incredibly stubborn villager, that’s my take right now
i don’t think a wolf’s first moves in the thread consist of getting into a dumb argument with someone over how to play mafia and suspecting them for scumreading someone else
it’s “too dumb to be a wolf”
TDTBW
copyrighted term, don’t use it

basically, i don’t think that wolf!leafia would start off the game by getting into an argument with luxy, arguably one of the strongest villagers here despite his break, and mindlessly pursue the read when the only basis for it is that he found sulit wolfy

i think wolf leafia would have more self-awareness than that

@Vulgard

geyde’s solving bothers me a lot

it feels like he’s been taking a sideline, critical approach of people’s play rather than getting more involved
i find that wolfy

@Vulgard

i’m struggling to figure out if apprentice is indirectly sheeping me or whether it’s a late mindmeld

The difference with his reads and the way he accuses people is huge.

I definitely see a big difference. His reads seem more fleshed out and logical here.

[Moleland]

You can bus a team mate at any point.

[Thunal33]

Oops didn’t know it would open all the spoilers when I quoted.

[Moleland]

@Insanity

Delete this. I literally thought there was a bug crawling in my phone screen

[Mistyx]

i also strongly dislike mole’s approach to reading vul fwiw

[Moleland]

I have Seth personally pretty ‘eh’ but Vul has scumread an ‘eh’ Seth before and been correct

[Insanity]

(Anyway, VC bot gonna go sloop for now )

[Thunal33]

Yeah that’s driving me crazy.

[yee-claw]

Read the first 100 posts. Planned to read the entire thread but everyone won’t stop posting. My takes so far:

Luxy

@Luxy

Wolfy Entrance

@Luxy

sulit has rolled wolf guys first scum caught

This is irony, still I don’t like the insistence on the joke that isn’t obviously funny by any means.

@Luxy

Weak attempt at a read tbh seems performative to start the game off strong

Luxy continues to try to shade people for no reasons.

@Luxy

/vote Vulgard

Luxy is clearly not following up any of his early accusations and just jumping in the most convenient wagon at the time.

Mist

The fact that Mist got instantaneously voted twice when they entered the thread, even joke votes, gives me a slight >v on them.

Vulgard

Vulgard started strong and gave me some town vibes. The post 46 ATE felt really performative, but is backed by him saying it was pre-written text. I like his pushes, but he is doing little to townread people. Might be a powerwolf redflag.

@Leafia

Me too. It’s too early in the game to seriously vote someone. Not sure I like how Vulgard is looking though to be honest. He should definitely be studied closely if he’s still alive by D3.

Someone needs to be the starter. I believe he is one of those people who vote not for lynching but for pressure?

Leafia

@Leafia

Trying to throw shade about already? Wow. That being said, we’re going to get more variety in our uniforms after this and who are the outlaws? I’m town and you know it so this’ll be a town win.

Mindmelt with me. I like this.

PKR

@PokemonKidRyan

Yeehaw it is high noon soon.
/Vote Surge

Appears out of nowhere to follow a wagon. If Surge is a wolf, consider PKR being on his team.

I’ll analyze Luxy more closely in a second.

[Thunal33]

Surge’s posts just feel like a bunch of nothing so far. He hasn’t done anything meaningful which doesn’t look great for him but I’m also reluctant to scumread him this early based on so little info.

[PokemonKidRyan]

@yee-claw

Appears out of nowhere to follow a wagon. If Surge is a wolf, consider PKR being on his team.

Out of context it seems bad sigh
I wish others understood context lol

[Trochilidae]

i’ve only spec’d in one game with Surge before and to say the least…he’s incredibly confusing, but he was a villager. however they’re still being incredibly confusing here. can someone with a meta read on him tell me if he does this as both alignments?