Vote Count
| Vote Target | Voted by | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Illwei | ArcticXI, WindwardAway | 2/7 |
| PokemonKidRyan | SirDerpsAlot | 1/7 |
This is interesting. I was more under the impression Marl was distancing fromā¦ well, everyone. Pointed some random fingers that probably didnāt land on scum, but nothing saying that they didnāt, either. I think Marl was playing cautiously and passed it off as being nonchalant. I donāt really get the impression the scum chat was very active, even when they were lurking, possibly because of the holiday. Otherwise Iām pretty sure their night kill wouldāve hit someone.
Agreed with Arctic on this, for the most part. I still wouldnāt rule out the possibility of one active wolf, but the wolf team composition kind of looks like it would either have to have two very active wolves, or two very inactive wolves, and the likelihood of two active wolves is very low considering theyād both have to be JoaT claims, and thatās just not something that looks very logical at this point. As Maple said, Eevee cleared them, and Iām not of the opinion that theyāre both wolves. It doesnāt work very well if theyāre not on the same side, so Iām still reading it as v/v.
Im still very uncertain of my reads but I am certain I want to vote within my PoE today.
And thatās still Derps/Illwei/PKR. I am uncertain of Shurian but Iād rather wait another day before making a call on their slot.
Vote Count
| Vote Target | Voted by | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Illwei | ArcticXI, WindwardAway, Intensify | 3/7 |
| PokemonKidRyan | SirDerpsAlot | 1/7 |
Ping me if this is incorrect
So you believe the scum team consists of 1 active wolf and 1 inactive wolf and that one of the Joat claims is probably a wolf?
none of the JOAT claims are mafia
the mafia is in the inactive people
thereās no way they would have messed up the kill if they are part of the JOAT claims and even semi-competent
Also, I think I saw it mentioned that Maple, Marl and Shurian are very experienced? (and I already know Eevee is). I havenāt played with those three before and Iām guessing Marl didnāt really expect to get yeeted by newcomers on D1 lol. Maybe they had a decent cover compared to meta in their previous games, but since a bunch of us hadnāt read them, it was easier to just vote them out.
Sorry, I should have clarified. I meant that I think both wolves are probably inactive. Usually Iād bet on one of them being active, in this case a JoaT claim, but the only one who I think could be a wolf with an inactive/lurking partner is Eli, and I really donāt think Eli is a fake claim (unless someone wants to insist on a JoaT B counterclaim right now). This is why I was still speculating on the JoaT actions even if it didnāt seem useful for town. Mafia already knows,so the JoaTs should be pointing fingers if they actually donāt believe each other are town. But so far, they havenāt, so my assumption is still that all four of them are town and Eli really did get RBād.
This is also a completely valid point, because they already would have known whom to target.The
I feel bad because I forgot to vote for extra time I wanna say sorry cuz I didnāt get to do it in time
2 Likes
Also arctic does make a point because somehow they attacked eevee and not me or eli LOL
1 Like
Itās hard to be precise when this is just theorising (The game) but maybe they thought the JOATs would be on each other and eevee was a free kill?
This is what I figured happened, actually, and itād also why I dont think asking people if they voted for extra time would be any help.
Presumably, but it still looks like a bad plan to me. Also means they werenāt paying much attention to interactions as I had my bet that min was not going to protect Eli anyway lol. They scumread Eli till EoD.
Not active during the JoaT claiming, sorry. People who were present were the four JoaT claims, myself, and then Light and Arctic who came in after but caught up and acknowledged that there were two of each JoaT claim.