Announcement: Updated Policy on Replacements

People normally say no before the game ends.

Scum still literally won that game even after they had to kill Leafia?

like i said, i believe the way i pre-format my scumcords makes it substantially harder for any activities to occur in which keeping them private would be desired

:eyes:

1 Like

ā€¦ That is not the point of a Lost Wolf
Signaling in-thread should be a last resort, or you wind up with ModeShifterā€™s poem

If you are Town and someone is clearly killed for reads when you as scum are known to kill based on mechanics then you can be townread for NKA

It doesnā€™t matter that scum won
They couldā€™ve done better

But kyo

This site never does NKA :^)

We do NKA
We just donā€™t do back-reading
Iā€™ve started to do back-reading more often as a result of Solicā€™s death in Danganronpa FM.

i wonā€™t pretend that this isnt invalid

people rely on meta a lot on this site

but if the only reason you donā€™t want scumchat published is because someone is against themselves being metaread, then i agree with orange here

you can find my scumchat for every game ive been in except JOAT9, thanks geyde and people still find me very difficult to metaread

granted iā€™m probably an exception, not the rule; but it feels mildly disingenuous to artificially make yourself harder to read because you refuse to let any scumchat with you in it be publicized

with that said, if you arenā€™t comfortable for other reasons (eg you said private things) then sure, if itā€™s too hard to delete that, i canā€™t deny that right

But thatā€™s literally just meta with extra steps.
Which is the same as discussion we were having about Leafia ā€“ if Chloe in this scenario had meta on Leafia, she would have better information on how Leafia would act?

Do you think that if everyone started playing on a new alt every game then each game would be ā€œworseā€.

But like

Iā€™m fine with public mafia chats that Iā€™m in

granted Geyde killed the JoaT9 one and BotF IV had none

Hot take: you arenā€™t that hard to read.

i donā€™t think im very hard to read but a lot of people will disagree with that

the point being that i take some pride in being a bitch to read but donā€™t think itā€™s fair to hide scumchats shrug

Yes and be able to act out her night actions accordingly
She couldā€™ve delayed Leafiaā€™s death for a day

Yes that would be absolutely miserable
Meta is a part of Mafia

Well I canā€™t wait for the anonymous FoL because my opinion is precisely the opposite.
Guess weā€™ll see.

1 Like

nah itā€™d be better if everyone was always an alt lol

Meta reading is part of the game
Itā€™s not hard to change meta
Alt games I only like to see if theyā€™re for the purpose of enhancing normal reading abilities

Imagine lying in scumchat to your partners cuz itā€™ll be public, so people get the false impression of your scum meta.

people use meta as the basis of their reads

instead of using meta to supplement reads

full alt games would have some positives and negatives

i think this is underselling the positives

with how much people rely on meta i predict full alt games to involve quite a bit more analysis because thereā€™s no meta to do it for them

you can read Arete because they posted a wallpost but you canā€™t read Estel for posting one

ā€¦ I donā€™t understand what you could lie about.