it could have, idk how reactiontests work really but even non-new players would give a reaction.
how valuable that reaction is, sure, but they would still, by definition, give a reaction
Flailing? Excuse me?
My tone is exactly natural, and it’s in my entire motive to support a dictatorship.
Breaking my eevee whisper to say arete bad.
As someone known for shitty reactiontests, i can spot a shitty reactiontest. And let me say, arete’s test is a whole new level of abhorrent.
Arete was confbiased the whole time. No matter what kyo did, arete was gonna scumread him.
NAI reaction, misunderstanding mechanics.
I can’t really gauge this reaction very well. Maybe kyo isn’t demon? that’s all i really gleaned from this.
arete goes full shade here. Not only assuming kyo is the demon(and not a minion), but shading him hard for what wasnt really an AI reaction.
Please explain this more @Arete
How is this scummy? I’ll admit, it isn’t townie, but “Oh. No you didn’t.” isn’t a very scum AI comment.
Basically arete explain your argument without just saying “kyo bad kyo flaining” plz.
1 Like
I’m being targetted for being a new player and it’s disgusting.
If I want anybody out it’s going to be Arete.
Their reaction test I believe was primarily to fish out Slayer reads.
The “Oh. No you didn’t.” is fine, that’s specifically what makes me think he’s probably not the Demon.
The scummy part is (a) the entire tone of his responses afterwards, which is very forced and unnatural, and (b) the way he uses it as an excuse to throw shade on me without actually justifying it properly.
I don’t see what reaction you ever get out of “why, because you are have scarlet wamen!”
thats just… shade.
1 Like
Again, Arete so far has contributed
- Shade
- Slayer reads to the scum team
They should be going this nomination.
…okay, think about this logically for a moment. I, knowing that I’m not the real Slayer, know that Kyo isn’t actually going to die no matter what he is.
And his reaction was in fact consistent with ‘Demon who knows there’s a SW alive,’ so I was curious how he’d react to that particular suggestion.
i feel like arete had the idea from the beginning of
“I am going to shade kyodaz for this test”.
why. how.
what posts were unnatural. What about them were unnatural.
I can say anything without evidence.
I think arete’s posts are indicative that they had a light breakfast this morning
This contributes nothing, without any evidence.
Literally all of them after I admitted it was a reactiontest, Marshal
All of them are using it as an excuse to attack me on the grounds that it’s ““blatantly-anti-town”” and making it seem like a far bigger deal than it actually is, and if you actually look at the tone it’s terrible
are you looking at the tone of the posts because I don’t know how to explain it better than that
What Arete’s claim did
- Did absolutely nothing to help town
- Fished out reads for scum to use, potentially fishing the actual slayer
- Sets up a potential future slayer claim to fakeclaim. They’ve also said that they shot D2 as Slayer once, so shooting that early to be unbelievable isn’t an argument. This would be a viable claim or Arete’s end.
- Screws flips when someone claims slayer in the future and can stop a person being cleared of Demon.
What they claim they tried to do
- Fish a demon claim
What Marshal is doing right now is known as the “Chainsaw Defense”
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Tarhalindur_Standard_Tells#Chainsaw_Defense
which is essentially where rather than actually looking at the evidence against someone, you defend them by attacking the person attacking them. While this isn’t universally done as scum – I’m sure we’ve all had the experience of thinking ‘X is attacking Y, and X is obviously scum, so Y is probably fine’ – it does indicate that if Kyo turns out to be scum, Marshal is very likely to also be scum.
no arete.
quote the posts. pick apart what was unnatural.
HOW! HOW! WHAT did they use an excuse to attack you. WHAT about the tone is terrible.
You can say anything is bad or terrible, but i want to know WHY you find them terrible.