I understand your point of view; you are really trying to bring out the deception in the social deception game. On the other hand, you are missing one key fact, the BD is not afraid to mislynch so even if there is a shred of evidence you probs will die.
Perhaps we should go look at the current roles in the game that can be outed (like Psychic being unable to link, Physician being unable to heal, etc.) and fix all of those before doing these, then.
1 Like
Phys is easy to fake, itās not really one of the main ones to worry about.
Itās mainly : noble, psychic,observer, butler, and drunk. Anything else does not really need a fake counterpart.
2 Likes
Semantics. You know what Iām saying.
1 Like
We already have been. Butler poison and the drunk HH message for example.
2 Likes
Whatās your idea to make it so a converted Psychic can fake a link?
1 Like
Letās compromise you make these classes with fake counterparts and every other class can be deceivable.
2 Likes
Rework Psychic into a neighborisor who is anonymus in his chat. Then give him a passive that says he is anonymus and that the passive sticks through conversions and other class changes (like royal blood).
2 Likes
I donāt think thatād be a good compromise. Thereās nothing in it for me to make 5 more classes, then say āEveryone else becomes a Toady!ā - itād be really confusing.
1 Like
Thereās a circle-jerk badge? XD
1 Like
The emapathetic badge. https://forum.imperium42.com/badges/39/empathetic
Give 1000 likes get 500
1 Like
You could do what I did with my faction suggestion. I made 2 classes per type. Which classes are converted to where depended on which type but it for example gave Obs its own class and gave Princess and the hard counter another.
So Knight an Hunter would be one offensive class which is nothing like them. And there would be another which Drunk and Butler would become which is along the lines of the Invoker.
Psy and Noble would get their own classes.
Psy and CW share a converted class but merc gets a unique one.
ect ect ect.
1 Like
So make a social and offensive converted class and everyone else becomes toady. Screw observer.
1 Like
Toady is fixed IMHO.
āEar Plugā day ability now gives UNIVERSAL excuse to not use a day ability. If people think youāre faking, theyāll likely think everyone you use it on is faking, too. This means that people will either be too cautious to call you on your bluff, OR, they will be so reckless that you can use Ear Plug to get other people executed under suspicion of faking.
āAnnoyā night ability now lets you redirect and prevent to someone else instead of yourself, and bypasses redirect immunity. This provides a UNIVERSAL claim that āI was redirected to someone and prevented.ā Again, either BD will be too worried to call you on it, or they will be so stupid that theyāll execute other people you use this ability on.
1 Like
Dude. What if someone asks for logs ANY time youāre evil? Like when youāre Reaper or Mastermind or Scorned? Thatās such an unfair and irrelevant question.
You have fake logs. Thatās the answer. Thatās always the answer.
Ear Plug ONLY prevents the target from hearing people talk, including hiding whispers sent to the target.
If you are reaper or MM or scorned or whatever you arenāt claiming a class you canāt fake. If you are converted from one of those classes then itās too late anyway.