[FoL] FoL23 - Day 4 - The Unseen and the Fool win!

Forum Matches Forum of Lies
#892

You don’t believe in gut reads then?

#893

I dont think forcing a read out of a new person would be bad, from what iv read they arent expected to be correct or have a super strong read its just getting their opinion

#894

Not really “gut reads” just a excuse to me, if you have no formal opinion on someone then a gut read is pretty much made up or forced.

#895

Derp wasn’t a gut read in that case either he did have some opinions on me based off his read.

#896

Nah man gut reads are important they are like when someone says something and u cant pinpoint an exact reason but it feels off. Gut is your best friend in these things, if you see something off just speak your mind about it

1 Like
#897

I personally wouldnt wanna make many gut reads, if youre wrong about it, it could seem really sus

[SFM] Rokugan FM {Game Thread} - Day 1 (1/1) - The Lying Darkness (WazzaAzza) won!
#898

Not true. If you expressly state it’s a gut read and people can gauge that you’re being authentic, it’s not sus to make a gut read. Gut reads can also have minimal info to back them

#899

And why even care about you looking yourself suspicious?

1 Like
#900

I just don’t believe in gut reads personally I feel like it’s a weak argument. I always believe in reasoning behind a read other then “just feel off about this person” if you feel like someone could be scum the best thing to do is read there posts and think about what makes you feel that way.

#901

Reads are always gonna be partially wrong, like no one is that good at this game. Well maybe some are, but reads are like a book, yor first chapter may be wrong, but your second and third build upon that learning from your mistakes and new info revealed through those mistakes

#902

If someone says its a gut read and they are town it would make me think what if they were a cult just tyring to get someone to seem sus withought needing evidence, but idk

#903

Why do you keep mentioning that it’s a Cult game?

6 Likes
#904

Then it would show in the entire post, not just the ‘gut read’ part.

#905

Alice makes a good point honestly. ;/

#906

I kind of am settled with Derp being likely a Cultist here, tbh.

1 Like
#907

maybe derp might be a neut mindgaming us, mentioning both cult and unseen

#908

Bad habit/subconsciously cult sounds better than evil

#909

What.

Unseen sounds cool too…and they’re purple.

#910

Before I’d shelf him as a newbtown, but his recent string of posts have way too many scumtells for me to ignore, really.

Repeatedly slipping that this is a Cult game, not wanting to look wrong with his reads, focusing on survival and what, and to top it off his post with him wanting to NK hunt was just disasterous.

Quite sure my original hypothesis with him being a Cult with a Ritualist is correct.

2 Likes
#911

Guess derp could be a pally slip or a cult slip.