My answer is that my opinion on Emilia hasnāt changed, and rather it worries me more that people seem to townread Emilia too easily. Nothing in her ISO deems any kind of townread in my opinion, and rather there are some actions that are indicative that she is mafia.
As for Eli, Iām at a similar position except I donāt think Eli has done anything outright scummy; people (I think it was Marshal?) immediately cleared Eli for existing and participating, which I still have a hard time accepting.
The last part was about a readlist - yes I do know what those are, but at this stage of the game, everyone is so clumped together any kind of tiering would be meaningless. All I can say is that I think Emilia is the most scummy and myself the least.
ketsuban is an alt, and i like the content ive seen from their slot (even beyond that but moreso with their identity in mind)
its sparse, this one is my probably least confident and im considering dropping it until I see more content but atm I just like some of their posts
This is a good sequence
This is a good read, again pretty unpartnered with arcy in general. Just some stuff that me likey.
Emilia is in her general combatative village meta, when shes arguing with people as town theres sometimes a villagery moment when you can tell shes genuinely in the right or believes as much and its towny asf.
This is a good post, correctly calls out faulty meta stuff
This is also a great excange IMO
And this post totally owned me tbh but its also villagery asf in context lol
Trying to get a song down, although Iām not sure that this discussion is entirely relevant here.
I can chat with you once the game is over (and maybe even post a recording!), but letās focus on this semi-competitive game for now.
Iād like to discuss Emilia with you, since they are my greatest scumread right now and yet you read them as scum. I see that you are mostly reading Emilia as town for āher general combatative village metaā as well as calling out Daisy (another scumread of yours) on a post.
Have they played a game as mafia recently, and do they have significant differences when playing as one alignment over another? Iām not sure we should rely on peopleās tones here since most people I know sound pretty much the same as either alignment.
not recently i dont think, we could have seen her wolf but someone posted their classcard so the game was reranded.
She used to have a super polarized wolf meta but i dont know how recent that is.
I am really just reading her on the metric of āwhen she argues, does it seem like she feels like shes in the right on the argumentā and this game I see it. I think this post particularly
comes from someone who thinks they are right here, espec how you never contested the reasoning. Find them likely to be town atm.