I’d like to see opinions on my readlist and to talk to people on people I may be wrong on/why
I’m going to be honest I read all of your post but I’m not sure if I actually processed all of it, how much of your wolfread on Cabbage + Emilia is based on associations vs. how much of it is independent? there are bits where you point out interactions that look partnery but also bits where you point out interactions that don’t and I can’t tell how much of your argument is ‘these posts look W/W’ and how much of it is ‘these posts just suck’
Gorta basing all his reads today on preflipping Cabbage W makes me nervous about his slot regardless of Cabbage’s alignment
for a moment I was like ‘WAIT but you said at EoD that you were trusting ME’ but I thought about it for like two seconds and it’s ?probably? just a typo
I think that yesterday’s EoD points to Cabbage being more likely to be a villager, no one except me was really trying to either change the wagons to Aelin or to put themself in a position to leverage towncred from Cabbage’s flip in a bussy way
…I guess that’s probably a less convincing argument to people other than me
Hey everyone! I’m back with a more functioning brain.
I see that I am once again the top wagon today. I expected as much, since after yesterday, I would be the easiest target once again for being the counterwagon to a village wagon.
That being said, hopefully I can counter some of the arguments that people have put out by explaining my thoughts behind my posts, so that if any mistaken villager is voting me or is thinking of doing so they can change their mind.
I will break up my post into a few separate posts, so that it is not too hard to read, and each individual point I make can be easily identified in one (hopefully concise) posts.
Before we go into everything I want to say, I want to cover my read of Arete. Although I do disagree with Hippolytus that posting immediately after the day starts is scummy (since I’ve done it as well before, albeit with considerably less words in my first post), I believe that the content within their first post today shows the disingenuousness of their read on Marshal.
Specifically, their first point on why Marshal is scummy - “useless questions and comments to try to look town that don’t actually do anything” - does not actually point to any scummy behavior. The posts that Arete mentions is more emblematic of Marshal trying to create discussion and poke the people into action, so it is unfair to say that they were not doing anything; in a slow game in which little more progress can be made with the given posts, Marshal’s posting could not be seen as not doing anything. Arete bloating this into a reason to scumread is definitely disingenuous.
he’s not town because he’s posting he’s town because he’s posting anything that remotely resembles actual content and not fluff
you can maybe apply that to the first post I quoted but they really don’t apply to all the posts where she was like ‘oh no, the thread is dead, this is so sad’ but didn’t actually do anything to try to change it or spark discussion or anything, saying that the thread is dead but not doing anything to make it not dead isn’t sparking discussion
pretty sure it was Amelia and the read was ‘Amelia posting → Amelia town’ even though all his actual posts were fluff
I was a host though and I didn’t read the entire thread so feel free to correct me if I’m wrong
Yeah it was Amelia and I hammered on her so hard to get her lynched and no one would listen until she committed suicide anyway