How to Make Maid a Reality in ToL

#41

Sheriff

#42

sheriff cant confirm people as not neutral. get a compatible check and one becomes confirmed - you just confirmed a BD

#43

Or you could get NS and confirm them then and there

#44

but they could be neutral like i said like i literally just said

#45

Knowing that one of 2 people MIGHT be scum is worse than knowing that 1 person is DEFINITELY scum

#46

Not to mention it gets false negatives if you check 2 scum

#47

but then you confirm 2 scum members likely, as ur a moron if u instantly assume compatibles are BD without further pressing it

it takes skill but it can be easily be equally powerful if not more so, and combined with the royal check makes it even stronger.

#48

But most of the time you will get the scum as you just ask for their claims and wills and hang the least convincing one, and THEN you confirm someone else.

It is different, not weaker.

#49

And gives to counter play to evils.

#50

The point is that the amount of skill you need to make full use of it given the time limit is high enough to justify making it 2 target

#51

2 target and it is by far the best investigative ability. BY FAR.

1 Like
#52

That way it is a trade of speed for precision instead of something with marginal use

#53

Not in Turbo

#54

compare confirmed townie to anyone everynight and you have a better sheriff check as can find ANYONE non-BD, including neutrals, not just unseen.

#55

princess has that as main ability in alpha and it was OP as shit so changed

#56

It is also super easy to tamper with even if you don’t know the person being compared with or who you are

#57

Add more framing abilities

#58

Oh and ability’s like follow and gossip are must better at confirming lots of players at once

1 Like
#59

2 everynight is way way way too strong. 1 everynight might be marginally too weak in some instances but that could be made up with strong limited use abilities. 2 everynight instantly becomes the best invest.

1 Like
#60

I’d argue otherwise. I am currently arguing otherwise