[Minimash] Community Forum Mafia 2 - (5/9/31) - Game Over - ModeShifter (Alice) Wins!

They have 250 posts, I can do that.

yes i have
if people bothered to read my posts instead of just callling me wolf for buzzwordy reasons you’d know that

Yes, uncharacteristically a lot actually, feel free to make a case on why I am scum though while I’m here. Meeting the bf again tonight, so just now here on a keyboard.

I suppose I deserve it for not being as aggressively villagery as usual, but I haven’t been quite sitting in the corner doing nothing all game.

I agree. We’ve miscleared someone. The question is who though? I highly doubt App is wolf here. Same with Dat and Hippo so I don’t think they’re miscleared. Solic is definitely town. Alice is looking slightly wolfy though I think. The possibility that she’s town exists though.

Apprentice is the most likely misclear.

Of all of them, he has the least hard-and-fast proof going for him. Bussing a wolf who was near-guarenteed to die D2 isn’t enough to get into the village core here. I realize we can’t go off of pelts like we normally do here, but come on.

Just because we don’t have many pelts to clear people with doesn’t mean the one pelt we do have shoould be used to shove an unimpressive slot into the village core.

No he isn’t. He’s the least likely misclear due to the suicide event. There’s no way that N.1 would’ve done what he did if App was a wolf. App was already in the towncore at the time, remember? Who in their right mind suicides when it’s possible that in doing so they’d take down a locktown scumbuddy? That’s beyond dumb.

Remind me of the structure of that event.

I refuse to believe that the event was designed in such a way that N had zero control over who died with him, so tell me the structure of the subgame.

So where I’m at, theres like three greencheck. One on Alice via desperado (if the desperado was normal desperado) since she is banned cant really ask Sulit for the exact details. We have Ici checked by Alice. And Leafia checked by App.

If I throw that whole bit of logic out. I can see them all as scummy.

So let’s go one by one and talk about which green checks I beleive. Leafia. This is the one I’m most conflicted on. As Leafia dead set for the past 3 days has basically said Alice is town and I scumread you if you scumread her. Now cause there has been some opposition to Alice, Leafia flipped on a dime. Not to help the only reason Alice was reading her as town because she thought Chloe was leafia. Like this slot has been so scummy to me throughout the game and like the constant I’m towncore cause of pushing people after they were pushed by like everyone else is like sure… you pushed em. Apprentice is in my towncore with me hip and Geyde. So like I want to believe he isnt pulling any shenanigans. But like to me I dont see a world where Leafia isnt playing like Insurgency so much of her play revolves around sheep or just omgus it’s insane. Her flip flopping right now to follow thread state on Alice after like saying shes lock town how cant u see is like so scummy to me and doesnt feel like a re eval.

Desperado shot Alice. Now usually i would be like yeah that clears the person. But again this is an eevee game and its Alice of all people. I had my doubts the minute after it was shot. And had to ask in my classcard. I essentially got a normal desperado would kill godfather like effects. But this is a eevee game and not even my own classcard is like normal. Theres been so much stuff I want to call bullshit on. Especially the auction 2. The reason u claimed 3p when in reality u werent in any pressure to do so. Not really trying to read me til after the event. Honestly I knew u had toaster for abit. And at first I was like she has to be controlling the others. As someone’s getting one per day in tandem to me. Yeah one shot at her so that threw my reads off of that idea. Ur whole process of getting the second auction items while provable by the gorta kill. Still feels like bologna as it feels like a weird event ability like mine. I feel ur role and mine are too similiar. It’s just everything in tandem makes me barely trust this slot.

Ici, gee god I have hated this slot. Great way to start this game is immediately get yelled at by like 3 people u trust (oddly two of them in this list) saying ur wolf for an opener. It felt fake and there was no analysis of the post itself but because it was more than a paragraph hes scum. I get it, my meta is easy as shit, but like the fact u cast me off based off of one post really hurt. Now u got checked by Alice who I dont trust at all, and it was with the event item I should have won. And ur claim is doctor but u havent even stated past night 1 what ur actions were. Like idk if ur at the point ur claiming ur role why havent u been like yes I healed X night 2. I guess I may be the only one in this boat where I would assume you would tell us what u been doing at night. Everything regarding ur slot has felt convenient and out of no where. I stand by you should have been D2 lynch with Italy ITA target d3 or TK target. But I feel like I’m the only one feeling this atp. Everyone else has swept u into maybe godfather role.

It’s like all 3 of these slots are scummy to me. If I had to pick one gth style on who’s the scummiest I would say Alice with Ici right behind. Leafia tbf I dont know her townrange. And like it could be she just plays this way regardless of allignment.

I’m atp where I say its Alice with a fake greencheck of her bud Icibalus. It feels to convenient that she got it, and who she used it on. That mixed with the cop check could have been a role check as well as it was choose you own cop. Alice could have used it to scout for chloe.

sigh Dat, it wasn’t the paragraph that made me read you w. It was the fact it was a rambly post that contained very little content.

1 Like

Of course he had zero control over who died.

from what I know

It was categories
everyone was given topics and could input answers, and whoever finished first could stop others from answering

N input the random answers really quickly so barely anyone could answer

everyone below a certain points threshold would die

Leafia, can you remind me again of your actions and why you took them this game?

That seems like awfully poor event design, doesn’t it? Tell me how the event worked.

Which players were competing in the game?

I don’t think there was a way for wolves to coordinate who died or for N to choose who died.

And I don’t think he makes a 2v6 suicide play. I don’t

only possible misclear from that, FMPoV, is dat, because his role could be an event survivor of sorts. I wasn’t there, so idk, maybe he survived regularly

N
dat
apprentice
Hippo
Ob_l1ight
Centuries
KyoDaz
Zone