Lol!malfunctioning ezpz gamesolve
(don’t mind this post, I’m just collecting whispers in one place where I can analyze them)
Summary
(to Light)
(to Whysper)
(to Light)
Ghana + Whysper 3
Ghana + Light 5
Ghana + Tangeld 1
Gorta could be town if you’re town and Ghana is Viceroy who poisoned you, or if you’re not town
So then I’m malfunctioning. Ghana’s Viceroy poisoning me. But that makes Gorta town, right? So then if one of Gorta/Magnus has to be fake (which I think we established is true for Whysper to be Retro), Magnus is fake. Then we have no Chieftain. So we have an Effigy. And now we have no Eclipse to move the clockhand, meaning that you should not have seen them both as good.
Whysper whispers
Summary
(literal duplicate of previous whisper, but with a ping)
(duplicate again)
(to Tan)
(to Light)
(to Light)
(to Ghana)
(to Ghana)
Whysper - Light 5-6
Whysper - Ghana 4-5
Whysper - Tan 1
how did I get different numbers for Ghana + Whysper when I counted for Ghana and when I counted for Whysper
no, because Gorta could have been poisoned N1 if it’s Retro game
it’s highly likely that the N1 target in a Retro game would be someone who gets info N1 (so Gorta/Magnus/GGhana/PKR/possibly Intensify) (looking just at claims, this is not a statement of belief in any of their claims)
and of those, Magnus’s info is almost certainly true via Light’s claim and Ghana’s info, if it’s a Retro game, is true regardless of his alignment
when you get a chance, could you tell me why you chose specifically GGhana to whisper for advice?
Tan whispers
Summary
to PKR
to Light
to Intensify
Tan + Whysper 1
Tan + Light 2
Tan + PKR 1
Tan + Intensify 1
note: while reviewing whisper logs for Tan I noticed that she explicitly denied GGhana’s whisper to her
You forgot me, and Intensify doesn’t claim to get N1 info. Light did in fact out his claim already, so I have no reason not to repeat it; he’s Warrior claim.
but your info seems to be ‘true-if-you-are-town?’ since we had to have two deaths at night somehow and a lot of things are pointing to a Retrogradus
In the interest of full disclosure, Ghana and I did in fact whisper later, after that refused whisper; we’re neighbors, so we didn’t actually have to do the accept thing, but he was doing it anyway because he forgot that. And I refused the first attempt because this was when he was still doing the roleswap and claiming Bloodletter; he was trying to tell me that he was doing a roleswap because I was pressing him and he couldn’t hold up the claim, and I refused because that plus PKR’s ping made me sure he was Minion who didn’t know how his claimed role worked.
1 Like
alright
in the interest of giving fair treatment to Town!you worlds let’s start from the beginning here
whose alignments are you confident on (in either direction, for either social or mechanical reasons) and why?