I also disagree it’s a faux pas to be honest. 
so far town:solic for activity at start of the game
italy:explained above
napoleon: reading activity?
Or it just devalues any pressure you might have had by spreading it thin over… lol it’s actually 10 people. Still going to CS you for this unless you’d want to try persuading me to your highest scumread, so I don’t have to guess out of 9 people. (excluding myself of course)
You’re a class that doesn’t participate into anti town massclaiming.
Except if you’re neutral. Neutrals are completely welcome to open claim ^^.
I’m new and I’m trying to see why this type of post is a good or bad idea. I’d kindly ask you to not CS me, but you choosing to CS someone based on D1 activity is a big mistake.
But what if there is no reason?
That’s in reference to you don’t need to claim to follow up on any investigative leads and get a person lynched. Claiming just gives evils more information since mechanical confirmability solves are nigh impossible in FoL.
What are you trying to say?
Says the only person who open claimed…? I’m confused.
And I’ll live with those consequences. That still isn’t directing me to your biggest scumread, so I guess you’ll bear the consequences as well. 
Town Reads
- Tangeld - I’ll be honest, Tanny was at first a null read to me as I didn’t take the time to look through her posts. but after I did, I’m convinced she’s town. Actively looking for clues, asking questions, and pushing to out information all stick out to me. And her townreads definitely does not look like buddying. Based on behavior, Tanny is my strongest townlean.
- Teleology - Tele, as I stated in my ISO, is trying to push for information and not rushing to conclusions. From what I’ve seen, there is no evidence of TMI and she looks to be focused in game-solving. She’s only slight because I feel like that it’s possible that she’s crediting me for my effort rather than for my behavior itself, but I don’t see Solic + Tele as a scumteam, and Solic is more scummy than Tele imo.
- Marshal - I sense a type of comfort ability from him that makes me put him on townlean. He feels pretty confident comparing his behavior to previous games and as I’ve said before, it feels like he has nothing to hide.
Null Reads
- Ozzkozz: He isn’t active much, but for the time he is acting, he’s making semi-decent to good posts. He’s probably the towniest of my reads.
- SirDerpsALot: I want to do a deep analysis into this guy and an ISO. On one hand, he wants to improve on reads but on the other, he seems a bit defensive. I’m going to take FoL23 into consideration when reading him. I found him to be a particular null read to look into.
- Cheeki: Cheeki is on the scum side of my null reads. I like some of his reads but I feel theres the possibility of TMI coming into them. When we established that Italy was an unlikely DI, they suspected them of being assassin/cl or NK, but not MM in particular. This feels like an odd development to me.
-Sogman: Came off as scummy to me first, as they looked like they might have wanted to buddy off Tan and Tele. I still consider them to be a scummy null lean as now they could be trying to buddy me. Their reads seem undeveloped and similar to other players. However, they don’t seem super hellbent on buddying and change up some of their townreads, like on Cheeki. I’m unsure.- H_Hja: Posted some meaningful things but overall not very active and a lot is fluff. Not sure about this one. They are a vet and I expect more. Scum-null.
- Everyone else
Scum Reads
-Italy - I can’t really distinguish my reasons from other players, as it’s mostly similar. Taking everything into consideration, Italy is most likely a neutral (not NK).
-Solic - Pushing for claims and applying pressure but not really analyzing. He’s a very slight scum-read for me and think there are better people that seem scummy.
**I feel like I’ve missed on so much… it’s difficult to analyze every player at the same time. There are some players I would like to investigate more into… specifically Derp.
There are some posters that I haven’t taken into consideration yet, I’ll do those after reading their posts more thoroughly.
1 Like
What if the reason italy isn’t claiming is because they’re an important class, like Prince? While this could be unlikely, it would give a reason why they aren’t claiming.
I’m not gonna bother reading the King yet… they seem irrelevant and will focus more into them d2 (if I live).
Italy shouldn’t claim and stop even referring to Prince. Any discussion regarding that only serves to out them.
Nobody pushed Italy for claim at any point, this is the first reference of this
You can avoid a CS by directing me to your highest scumread handily. Your claim is not your shield. So if you’re Mystic/Prince/Priest, get off your ass and play the game instead of claiming under some pressure. This is not an invitation to discuss this further, because that’d only lead to more Prince discussion.