[NFoL] Newbie Forum of Lies 4 - Day 4 - The Blue Dragon and the Plutocratic King win!

[Marshal]

Can you just make 3 categories.

Townlean
Null
Scumlean

and put everyone where you think they belong?
maybe elaborate on it too?

[Cheeki]

post about anybody else, we’ve heard your thoughts on solic enough
post about the active players, the fact you’re actively avoiding it is so suspicious to me

[Napoleon]

The ones that I am most certain of.

[SogMan]

@Napoleon

So everyone reads Solic as town/null. Taking all factors into consideration, I actually have a slight scum-read on him. Asking questions and applying pressure is easy, but he doesn’t give any analysis. I just don’t know what to take out of his refusal to post his reads right away.

@SogMan

i kinda agree with this, and he didnt even respond to the suspicion. just made a meme-ish post about the cs

update on my reads: slightly scumreading solic, reasons above

[Tangeld]

@SogMan

my townreads are tele and tan, everyone outside of it is null

@SogMan

also cheeki

These are the posts that I specifically reference. He gives townreads on three people, but doesn’t explain any of them, which to a third party can look like a groupscum cover or a scum trying to pocket townies. Kindly explain the logic behind your reads @SogMan , particularly townreads because just saying that someone seems town gives very little info and can accidentally cover a scum if everyone takes it at face value.

Also worth noting that “everyone outside of it is null” offers no scumreads, which is strange because there should be at least some form of scumread in all of this. You ought to be looking for scumtells as well as finding town in which to place trust.

[Solic]

Parroting reads is bad y’all. Got anything else for us? You’re genuinely a great reader Hja. Just need to let it be heard some more again.

[Napoleon]

@Teleology what are your reads?

[Marshal]

He gives a little more insight on tele but after that not much more elaboration

[Emilia]

I asked you about that post only because I did already make that read

[DatBird]

well imma start my commute home, be back later
no massclaims while im gone

[SogMan]

@SogMan

copied because its not letting me quote from the search tab

tele: Personally, Solic seems to be trying to lead the court FMPoV. He is being skeptical of everyone’s comments and asking them for their thoughts. This reads as town to me, but at the same time he is an experienced player and could just as easily be open wolfing as scum.

tan: I’m fine with rescinding my scumread on Italy, but I want to see him contribute more. As it stands, he seems like he desperately wants to be left alone, which coupled with the aforementioned break of character strikes me as odd.

after ISOing cheeki i take back my townread, didnt like encouraging neuts to claim d1

here you go. as i said, very bare bones. i dont have an actual idea of anything yet.
also at that point i didnt have a single scumread. right now kinda solic

[Italy]

Alright, Napoleon seems like a pretty likely town since he’s making incredibly large walls of text justreading out things that make people suspicious or less suspicious. An evil wouldn’t want to point out who’s confirmed, because that’s less people who can take the blame for their actions.

[Solic]

Well sure, but do you have thoughts on any other players?

[Emilia]

No
I will be more active when i finish Watching movie

[Solic]

Why doesn’t this “evil wants to lead the court” rhetoric apply to Napoleon?

[Solic]

All right, enjoy your movie.

[Marshal]

Gah I was gonna make a teir list for reads but i have to login with twitter and I don’t use all of that

I guess y’all are just gonna have to make lists yourself

[Italy]

Evils don’t want to confirm people, they do want to lead the court.

[Italy]

The more people who are confirmed, the less people who can take the fall instead of the evils. If the evils lead the court, they can push on BD without one of their buddies ever getting randomly put on stand.

[Napoleon]

My point still stands though. I’ve yet to seen analysis from you. I’m not debating that parroting reads is good, but if I recall correctly (and if I’m wrong, point me to the post), you didn’t stop the parroting of reads on other players, only on yourself. You are getting a bit defensive here.