Opinion Thread: The Fool (ToL)

Please tell me the next time that you get a Prince exed for being the antithesis of Scummy

I’m the scummy player.
My scumreads are good, but I will always appear as scummy.

And you want to punish the scummy player? Why the fuck? They are not intentionally scummy, in most of all cases.

I’ve played ToL with you, Priestess, you don’t usually appear scummy when you aren’t scum

Except when I claim Scorned as Prince :thinking:

I don’t want to punish the scummy player beyond lynching them

1 Like

What is scummy to you

You should never encourage people to mislynch BD just because they dont act exactly how you want them to

If you actively look like scum Priestess, then it’s a player problem, not a game problem.

I have fiiinals

are you asking for a general definition or specific examples?

You can be a hecking good player and still look scummy.

That’s a strawman and you know it

1 Like

No, it’s not meant as one?

Is a BD pushing for an exe on a Prince not scummy?

Does that mean it’s a good play?

Just because

Doesn’t mean that it’s a good play.

If you can’t recognize fool from scum then it’s a player problem not a game problem

1 Like

Definition you are using

Fool is supposed to be unrecognizable from scum.

We don’t want to lynch people for bad plays. We want to lynch them because they are evil.
Because every single player will define “bad play” differently. It’s just a thing of taste.

Scum is supposed to be unreasonable from villager

If you can’t find fools as fools, you should learn to better scumread I guess? Because a lot of people are good in it

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Scummy