Opinion Thread: The Fool (ToL)

#281

Please tell me the next time that you get a Prince exed for being the antithesis of Scummy

#282

I’m the scummy player.
My scumreads are good, but I will always appear as scummy.

And you want to punish the scummy player? Why the fuck? They are not intentionally scummy, in most of all cases.

#283

I’ve played ToL with you, Priestess, you don’t usually appear scummy when you aren’t scum

#284

Except when I claim Scorned as Prince :thinking:

#285

I don’t want to punish the scummy player beyond lynching them

1 Like
#286

What is scummy to you

#287

You should never encourage people to mislynch BD just because they dont act exactly how you want them to

#288

If you actively look like scum Priestess, then it’s a player problem, not a game problem.

#289

I have fiiinals

are you asking for a general definition or specific examples?

#290

You can be a hecking good player and still look scummy.

#291

That’s a strawman and you know it

1 Like
#292

No, it’s not meant as one?

#293

Is a BD pushing for an exe on a Prince not scummy?

Does that mean it’s a good play?

Just because

Doesn’t mean that it’s a good play.

#294

If you can’t recognize fool from scum then it’s a player problem not a game problem

1 Like
#295

Definition you are using

#296

Fool is supposed to be unrecognizable from scum.

#297

We don’t want to lynch people for bad plays. We want to lynch them because they are evil.
Because every single player will define “bad play” differently. It’s just a thing of taste.

#298

Scum is supposed to be unreasonable from villager

#299

If you can’t find fools as fools, you should learn to better scumread I guess? Because a lot of people are good in it

#300

https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Scummy