im not trying to like stir up drama or shit but like why is my read actually bad anyone willing to tell me that?? or??
marl voting correctly at eod is >rand W
Summary
im joking i just like making fun of marl ily marl
1 Like
no CONROY IVE BEEN CALLING GORTA OBVIOUS V I JUST SAID YOUR METHOD SUCKS
AAAAA
AA
A
A
france
its not only false to read gorta solely off of wim and postcount, but doing so only encourages him to play in a way that requires zero effort, and thats not something iād like to do
i dont want to encourage people to do jack shit lol
i do think his wim being higher is more indicative of him being a wolf, as he loves the rand
but theres also the possibility that hes trying to change how he plays to not be a megaslanker
i think his current confidence in sulitsulitsulit is villagery, and hes solving around how people are treating him, which is good
@Mistyx can you walk me through nightingale v again?
I know youāve been posting things abt it a lot but I donāt rlly have a collected case I can sheep and u feel like the only one putting the read out there
Response Initial Townlean
Reading this made me understand why Arete townleaned Marshal. In that post, I found some stuff which made me remember why I donāt townread Marshal (other than the random fact that she wanted a CFD on me at EOD1) such as:
Return Of The Darkness Upick - [D2] - Augur (15/17) - #2184 by Marshal
However I also found a (weak) reason to townread her:
Return Of The Darkness Upick - [D2] - Augur (15/17) - #2322 by Marshal
(Itās weak because itās AtE, and it would feel odd to see it coming from scum.)
Response App/Marshal not W/W
I disagree with this post where āApp/Marshal canāt be W/Wā because of said interaction.
Return Of The Darkness Upick - [D2] - Augur (15/17) - #1732 by Apprentice
Return Of The Darkness Upick - [D2] - Augur (15/17) - #1752 by Marshal
Return Of The Darkness Upick - [D2] - Augur (15/17) - #1755 by Apprentice
Return Of The Darkness Upick - [D2] - Augur (15/17) - #1756 by Marshal
What I see between the two are:
- App claiming wolf
- Marshal asking App to say something
- App actually saying the line Marshal gave him
- Marshal laughing
I am not saying that App/Marshal are W/W; I am saying that -based off this conversation- I donāt see why App/Marshal canāt be W/W.
I donāt see why -assuming Marshal is scum- she canāt simply either laugh in joy at a gamethrowing town, or have a final talk with App before the latter inevitably dies.
I donāt see the same image that Arete sees.
I think this take only makes sense if you assume that Wind knew the exact wagons, which is actively negative likely to be true because an incorrect votecount was posted about 10 posts earlier
although 2 people switched to her after that VC, I donāt think she would have expected to be going over there (because if Datās VC were correct, Derps would still have been ahead of her)
I think the most likely explanation for that post is āshe didnāt expect she was dying but she wanted to look like she was trying to solve while dying because she thinks that looks townieā which is ~NAI for Derps
and apart from that I think that her hardpush on Derps is fairly unlikely to be bussing, like, I didnāt read all of Umineko 2 but I know she randed scum on a team with Seth and both of them endgamed, which makes me think that sheās not a huge bussing enthusiast? maybe thatās too much of an assumption but I doubt ārandomly hardbus your teammate for no reasonā would be her preferred style