The assassin would be immediately replaced and then the MM can convert again
One word to say to that suggestionā¦
No.
We donāt even know if there could be a Fool in play, and we donāt know as well if the Fool has been changed yet either, so unless there are slips or any contradictios or anything, best not to
1 Like
And the Lunatic can convert if accused or executed.
Think of it as a mini-MM.
1 Like
We already have a confirmed Alchemist/Plague Doctor. I doubt we have a Fool in play. And it would be nice to get them out early.
In addition to the lynch on Marl, he talked Daystart. Fool tends to stay quiet the whole day.
In the majority of cases, nolynching in a game is a bad thing.
As Iām sure that youāve probably heard yourself Wolf.
Executing someone gives us information.
So why would we miss out on that valuable info which would could stand to gain?
If we hit an Unseen, we can look for associations and work from there.
Iād rather Lynch a Fool than keep them alive and allow them to be a potential Lunatic too.
1 Like
And here I was thinking that you actually had something good, until you said that which Polik just reminded usā¦
But the chances of MM converting Fool and having a Fool in the game is very low. If a Fool is rolled itād be in our best interest to execute them D2.
Not saying I donāt. Iām disagreeing with the random lynch though, and until we have had a chance to hear form everyone, and there is one person Iām currently trying to get a lock on
And can people guess who Iām talking about right now. I did mention, they might be the best pl d3 or d4
I mean, itās not really random. Itās a 2/5 chance of hitting Scum if you, PKR, Hippo, Nuclear and Eevee is not scum.
Iām considering giving you a hint why I can;ā be scum, but itās not a good idea yet for me
1 Like
Itās a higher chance it will benefit the Unseen if you think about itā¦
Thatās why I suggested wait for everyone else to come up, give their results and then decided where to go from there. But at this moment, hard claiming and soft claiming really is not the best thing to do. What eevee did could be considered pro-BD yes, but he also could have given the Unseen what he becomes the first night, especially that everyone is essentially convertible
Actuallyā¦
Executing anyone, benefits everyone:
- BD, executing BD. Confirms the presence of a class. Making it so we can slowly create an idea of what theyād have done and make lists from there. Yes, thereās doubt. However, thereās always a chance weād be right
- Unseen executing BD. Well -1 member against them.
- NK executing BD. -1 member against them
- Neutral executing BD. Speeds up the game making it so they win quicker
- BD, executing Unseen. No need to say.
- Unseen, executing Unseen. Weird, but allows for them to convert again maybe if they want that to happen
- NK executing Unseen. Catches BD off guard as theyād be rushing to find final couple Unseen instead of NK
- Neutral executing Unseen. Speeds up game for them.
- BD executing NK. -1 KPN
- Unseen executing NK -1 KPN. Unlikely theyād be killed at all except executions or lucky actions
- Neutral executing NK. -1 KPN. Less likely to be killed
- BD executing Neutral. Reduces what neuts we can have. Good for PoE
- Unseen executing Neutral. Good for PoE, gives them ideas of who to convert based on how much people are leading
- NK executing Neutral. Less people to die if not something which can directly win from the get go with NK
- Neut executing Neut. Maybe wincons are conflicting (Merc vs scorned)
