Genuinely? There’s no real nice way to say it, but I don’t really like it. I don’t think that Sarah was an optimal person to ISO dive, most of the stuff you quoted as bad was logically just a person having fun and getting settled into the thread.
Thanks, I plan to ISO dive everyone and I only think the stuff I quoted as bad was because I have been seen scum act like that in the last few games here.
Peter is next on my list
Ok so I’m an idiot.
I might have overestimated my ability to read this thread and I am super behind.
I’m probably gonna be unable to talk during EoD due to me not having caught with the thread.
I will still be here though if you need any last minute questions.
talk to us now and catch up over night
What do you want me to talk about though.
Im awaketh cutting it close as my sleep schedule is shit, and I cant play unless im on my pc so :^)
I will get to the andy iso rq as I promised alice.
I think the kings allies picks were dumb af
I liked the group that susan/edmond brought up a lot more
Mary still hasnt impressed me from her new posts
And i have one other thing that i mentioned at SOD that I really want everyone to do, but I will talk about that in a second post as that post is where i will get the data
just give us your thoughts from where you stopped reading
OK so if u can please at this time respond to this post if you are awake before EOD to get some early consensus reads from everyone, this will help for NKA, general mindset of game, and have reads of players to see if they change later (mainly to check for progression)
@Gilbert_Lovell
@Peter_Carew
@Geoffrey_Bailey
@Mary_Savill
@Andy_Bernard
@Alan_Atlee
@Sarah_Lacey
@Lucy_Wrenne
@Jane_Drayton
@Susan_Ailemer
the rest of the pings will be in the replied message
Please read the message that this is replied to and answer
@Emma_Maison
@Nicolas_Adams
@Thomas_Scott
@Isabel_Savage
@Alice_Alard
@Ivo_Wake
@Edmond_Bailey
@Helen_Harte
My ISO had my thought mostly
I left when the thread state was dead and just kinda empty with no more direction.
Doing a very quick re-read of Ivo, since I have forgotten a lot of their posts.
Can’t tell if that’s a good thing or a bad thing.
They happen to have the most memorable profile picture to me, but the least memorable posts.
For someone with a bright pink pfp, they sure don’t stand out.
They seem slightly self-aware of their activity levels at the beginning.
Focus on Thomas for a while. ~20 posts or so?
Post on Sarah isn’t AI. Doesn’t ping me either way.
Post on Isabel feels genuine. Not truly AI, but I like the feeling I get from it.
Helen post feels useless. They have a dropdown [Summary] that includes 3 quotes.
Susan post feels empty.
I keep opening these dropdowns expecting big juicy walls and there’s not a whole lot of anything.
My brain works in a weird way - I keep wanting to townread this player for using dropdowns because they could very easily just post these big quotes normally and look like they’re doing more than they are. The problem with this is that… there isn’t a lot of content within the dropdowns!
Earlier I said “this player looks like they’re doing less than they really are” and at this point in the ISO I take that back. I haven’t seen anything notable.
I want more of Ivo interacting in real time.
The next section from Ivo feels incredibly pure:
Unsure if anything here is particularly alignment indicative, but I get good vibes. Wish I could explain more.
It’s cute
And cute = town
Duh
Wrote a wall on Jane while Jane was in the thread. They aren’t afraid to interact with someone who came out of the gate strong and solvey.
I’m pretty null on Ivo. Slightly townie.
I get good vibes as well as bad vibes from them. I’m flippy.
Perhaps I’ll look at them again overnight when I’m not doing the fastest skim in the world.
My top 3 atm:
are pretty much the same from last night with the added bit that I still dont think Mary has said anything that pings me as town
- Gilbert_Lovell: a standout i remember is putting actual effort into their Thomas read rather than just say ew annoying, it’s a good look.
- Peter_Carew: null so far, barely any content to read
- Geoffrey_Bailey: early posts were lackluster but they say they’re going to put in more effort and i’ll give them that chance.
- Mary_Savill: not many posts, i’ve liked what i’ve seen though she hasn’t earned towncred for it yet.
- Andy_Bernard: eh, can’t say it’s my favorite slot they’ve tried to analyze, yes but it hasn’t been the most impressive.
- Alan_Atlee: even though i disagree with most of his Allies picks, will lean him as GK for the moment, never a priority now though.
- Sarah_Lacey:
- Lucy_Wrenne: townlean, solvey from the get-go and i haven’t seen a reduction in this, good tone as well.
- Jane_Drayton: little posts but i like what i’ve seen so far, not much else to say here.
- Susan_Ailemer: small-brainmeld, can’t believe i’m actually reading into a meme but even aside from that this is a townlean of mine.
- Emma_Maison: probably the most WiM in the thread tbh, will townlean them as well and a good Allies pick.
- Nicolas_Adams: not much of particular note aside from trying to solve in the chaos, i remember disliking some of their takes, i’ll have to look back and see.
- Thomas_Scott: no
- Isabel_Savage: it’s been said that sometimes their interactions just feel off and i agree tbh. it’s mainly a vibe instead of an actual read but i’ll be watching them.
- Alice_Alard: kill she wants obs dead really, i townlean this slot. i’ve loved all the analysis and it seems to be in good faith.
- Ivo_Wake: i was initially wary but i’ve warmed up to her and the recent isos are only helping her case.
- Edmond_Bailey: lockscum policy cuddle pls
- Helen_Harte: would love to see more from, null atm due to lack of content.
i present bailey’s EoD snapreads
Top Town
Lucy, Alice, Alan
Top Scum
Ehh I’m not very sure yet tbh, still haven’t caught up so these reads are kinda bad and inaccurate.
can you at least provide some from the content you have read?, the lack of any worries me
There was much more to work with in Sarah’s ISO, but I can’t say much about this slot. Like there is nothing to work with here. @Peter_Carew you need to get more active and play the game you signed up for. That playstyle is a detriment to the town. This can stay a null
am a dumbass and forgot this one
only 7 posts so far, seem a bit disjointed? brings up interesting points near the end of her iso, would like to see more from in general.
I don’t really want to make half-inaccurate reads tho. I’ll probably have my reads in my logs once I’ve done more ISOing and catching up
(Helen): There isn’t much to work with again, but I will make it work. Their ISO is just “Thomas annoying” and it honestly seems performative. Like a wolf trying to be helpful to avoid being scum read. This is another slot that needs to do more tomorrow, but for now this is a null leaning scum read for me.