Right, so I’ve been waiting for PKR to answer my question, but it doesn’t look like they’re planning on doing that. Case should already be enough anyway.
Reasons for wanting NK out
I’d have to check but I don’t remember PKR being this (inconsistently) focused on NK in other games with an NK (Like in ToS2, although conversion reason doesn’t apply there).
Weird concern about appearance
Mainly caring way too much about looking good. Also weird phrasings (Trying to TMI themselves town? I didn’t really explain this very well but I don’t know how else to explain it) that I doubt come from town.
Odd mechanical “cluelessness”
I don’t think someone this focused about mechanics would actually not know these. I think PKR is faking them to look townier.
Mindset inconsistencies
Doesn’t really seem to actually be hunting for NK, and other stuff.
Incorrect/Odd Analysis More likely to notice “NK slips”
Summary
Claim Inconsistencies
Case
You can’t know that for sure though? Why even say this? Anyway, the main point is that they didn’t mention NK and care too much about not looking bad.
Why?
Don’t believe super much in this one in particular, but it doesn’t really seem like they’re trying to lynch NK here?
Don’t believe this analysis actually comes from Town PKR. Like, regardless of whether or not Frostweaver caused the bleed or is even in the game, we should be careful because of healing bleeds.
Doesn’t really consider us being a possible NK here, like he later sort-of-but-not-really does with Wazza, even though he claims he’s mostly hunting for NK.
Don’t believe Town!PKR actually says this. Town can keep track of claims themselves, no need to make it easier for scum. Besides, it doesn’t really help to know someone’s claim unless they can prove themselves with it.
Not really a point against you, but about what?
Red part looks like TMI that Wazza isn’t the NK, since NK and NK-helper are basically the same thing, yet you clear them from it. Then, at the end of the post, you retract clearing them from it, for whatever reason?
Not really AI, but like I mentioned before, that wasn’t actual analysis - You listed all of the possibilities.
I highly doubt someone who is heavily focused on mechanics, and prides themself for it would make such a ridiculous “thought” and actually believe in it.
Cyan part doesn’t sound like actual analysis, as that are basically just all of the possibilities.
I can’t really explain why, but these kind of posts sound very fake. I think they rarely ever come from town.
You said you were sure the NK was Frostweaver, yet called Unknown out for “TMI” that the NK was Darkstalker. This is even disregarding the fact that what Unknown said was unlikely to actually be TMI.
Like, if that was TMI, you could also say the orange part is TMI that Frostweaver spawned.
This. I hate it. With a passion. Highly doubt it ever comes from town.
I didn’t explain them super in-depth, as I think most of them are pretty self-explanatory (with the guide given). If anything isn’t clear enough, just ask.
So in scenario that this is a Frostweaver game, Magnus (or me, or both of us) dying in the same night would almost always confirm this as a Frostweaver game.
In a scenario where Magnus dies while you attempt to heal him, it almost always confirms a Darkstalker game and I still don’t believe that someone would curse Magnus only to immediately kill him, since there’s a chance that Seth is GK and he suicides through Dust + he was already bleeding. Would you waste your attack on a bleeding target if you were NK? I wouldn’t.
Well yes, but that reason still applies. If someone is LW, they are more likely to see LW slips/softs, if someone is NK, they are more likely to see “NK slips”.
ruh
