Town was completely atrocious there, so it was a fair win.
SF4 town won dominantly. SF1 town also won confidently.
I guess you could argue it’s somewhat balanced as it is now.
Literally the only reason I proposed this suggestion is to prevent game from getting boring, because without explosions there is no point to the setup.
I’m not even saying there are no better ways of doing this, it was basically a random idea.
I disagree with your take on it though.
I disagree
I think being very cautious and conservative on usage of the red button can be an exciting strategy in its own right and it shouldn’t be banned
That would be subjective, I guess, but imo no one signs up to play nightless mountainous.
It’s different than nightless mountainous
Since there is always the threat of the red button, whether you choose to push it or not.
It’s up to Marshal anyway.
My opinion from looking at previous games is that banning detonations and using only lynches first several days is a good strategy for town, as scum would have a mighty difficult time.
For example, with 16 players, scum would have maximum 4 instant detonations available to them.
Which means they need reduce player count to 12 at least.
So 4 mislynches in a row, and that if we consider that they would be somehow still spread out after all this and able to detonate town, which is unlikely.
And if scum bunches together (for example), they would need 7 mislynches in a row.
I don’t think that’s a great or exciting way to play this setup, even though I think it’s a beneficial way for village.
I think that would make setup like vanilla nightless 8v4, except significantly more difficult for wolves.
Rule wouldnt break game but its entirely unnecessary considering at least 3 ppl insta det every game cuz they’re dumb
Also half the players forget it’s an fm and go on a power trip lording it over their target lol
It’s mostly randomized but mafia can choose whether they want a town detonator or mafia detonator (or random).
