Vanilla Flipless FM — Vote on reroll or can

Forum Matches
#981

Then don’t have it labelled as a newbie game :confused:

#982

The real problem is vet tryharding in NEWBIE games.

#983

@Abkaal you should join the Warhammer game hosted by eevee

#984

What do you want people to do, just not try?

#985

@Abkaal https://forum.imperium42.com/t/battle-of-25-armies-warhammer-fantasy-fm-signups-19-25-oh-yea-6-factions-game-what-could-go-wrong/73568?u=luxy

#986

You are taking that post so offensively when it wasn’t even meant to be that way.

#987

Newbies don’t learn anything when the Town Leaders and veterans do all the work and gamesolving for them. This was what I was saying before the game even started.

#988

Who was Maf, Captain and Geyde?

1 Like
#989

I want players to try.

But to my point, the only newbie of this game never really knew what was going on.

When one of the vets gamesolves d1 in a newbie game, with none of them having input, that’s a problem.

1 Like
#990

Yes.

#991

Captain slipped real hard

#992

‘I would do that as town’

1 Like
#993

There was only one newbie.

#994

I get it, it’s not actually fair.

However we don’t have 9 newbies

#995

So why was it labelled newbie friendly? Just call it flipless Mountainous and leave it at that. I understand the whole newbie thing was Math’s idea but it never was gonna turn out like that.

#996

At a base level, some people played this game competitively. The players who played it competitively aren’t in the wrong for doing so, but as a newbie game where the primary goal is player learning, that interest conflicts.

I stated it before and I will state it again, players will not learn when a veteran solves the game with no input from others.

I propose a Hydra Newbie game where only the ‘new’ player in the team can speak on the thread chat.

It forces the newbie to step up, but also provides them with a coach to help them through things they might miss.

#997

Then the newbie becomes a microphone for the vet to use to speak their ideas

“Hey say X Y and Z”

#998

We tried thinking of the same exact idea

#999

Has it actually been attempted in practice?

1 Like
#1000

Actually no it hasn’t.