Watch Your Mouth!: Sophomore Year (3/17) - Day 5 - Planters (Mafia) Win!

[Luxy]

I know I’m town

Insanity is a townread of mine

Mole is at worst Null

Whysper is individually scummy

Eli is the only thing I agree with there

Everything else is concensus

The wavelength is signficantly altered

[Luxy]

That is why I think at this point he is more likely to be a wolf than a wrong townie

[Luxy]

@Marshal

question-dodge

Where did I question-dodge Marshal I swear I answered your question in every post lol

[Marshal]

Are you seriously telling me that just because somebody has different reads than you, it’s wolf AI?

@Wazza

Null

Insanity
Moleland

Scumlean

Luxy
EliThePsycho

@Luxy

Mole is at worst Null

he literally has mole in null

did you read the post?

because he has 4 people in null + wolves and you disagree with them you think he’s likelier wolf?

get out of here with that. That’s not good reasoning my guy, you should know this! Even if you are right, town can be wrong and because he has different reads does not make him likelier to be wolf.

---

@Insanity

Gorta

Jane
Moleland
Eli

look at insanity’s bottom 4. 2 townreads of yours, 1 null, 1 wolfread.

is insanity wolf?

your mindset is super inconsistent and your rolecard is red

[Luxy]

@Marshal

because he has 4 people in null + wolves and you disagree with them you think he’s likelier wolf?

get out of here with that. That’s not good reasoning my guy, you should know this! Even if you are right, town can be wrong and because he has different reads does not make him likelier to be wolf.

Mate don’t fucking patronise me I don’t think you’re reading what I’m writing at all

Whysper is the more likely wolf, and Wazza fits in as wolf if she is.

@Marshal

look at insanity’s bottom 4. 2 townreads of yours, 1 null, 1 wolfread.

is insanity wolf?

your mindset is super inconsistent and your rolecard is red

No because I townread him?

Marshal you know how I play, I go by tone and then pick the people I don’t like and go further into them.

Plus Insanity’s reads are not nearly as bad as Wazza’s and make sense.

[Luxy]

Whatever at least Marshal is creating content here the first 700 posts are just stale and lack life

[Luxy]

Feel like this the first argument in thread all game which is good

[Insanity]

Is this me back in FoL 30

[Marshal]

whatever

I don’t want to make an ass of myself if i’m wrong so i’m not going to insta-condemn you

but I still want some explanations.

@Luxy

@Marshal

the fuck is this??? “She kind of implicitly makes a decision Esquiddy would be a good lynch”. How did you infer that???

Half of her ISO is talking about whether esquiddy is ‘actually’ new or not, which is not only throwing shade but also indicating that he’d be a good lynch in her mind.

1. In what posts (with quotes) did whysper imply esquiddy was a good lynch, and why

2. Can you quote the “half of her ISO” talking about if Esquiddy is new. I see 2 posts, 1 questioning it and then 1 responding to being corrected and acknowledging that.

[Luxy]

@Marshal

but I still want some explanations.

And I can provide

[Luxy]

Posts mentioning Esquiddy:

@Whysper

Esquiddy & Jane - never played with them, so not familiar with their play styles

@Whysper

I’m not sure that I’d read it that way. Could also be an attempt to question why Derps would be out of the PoE. I’d say NAI.

@Whysper

Oh, I was actually wondering how new he is. He acted like a newbie in some regards, but he also talks about analyzing people as towny and scummy, so I don’t get the impression he’s completely new to the general game. Also, he voted for Derps pretty early on in his 4th post. That’s interesting. He gave no reasoning (which I think I will ask after this).

Also, Derps seems to be on a few lists for hard-to-read. So I think he might easily be put in the PoE.

@Whysper

Oh this is a good point too. Newb wolves still have partners.

@Whysper

This makes me think Esquiddy isn’t very new. How can he say that Derps is always suspicious?

@Whysper

Oh okay, not completely new, but fairly new like me.

@Whysper

So do you think his push on you is just because he knows you the most and is suspicious about you in general?

@Whysper

Yes, probably mostly that I haven’t seen him as wolf, though his town behavior comes off as wolfish due to not really helping and sometimes actually hindering like in FoL 30 that just ended. I checked SFoL 61 (I guess 61.5) and it appears he’s town there. I’ll search other games he’s been in.

@Whysper

Esquiddy - I originally had him a SL for his vote on Derps. There’s since been an explanation, so I’ve moved him up to null. He’ll possibly go into TL, but haven’t seen enough yet.

9/43 I guess I did exaggerate about half but that was because she also had a lot of replies to him which I ‘counted’ as posts about Squid which is my fault.

It’s still a significant portion however.

---

Posts suggesting Squiddy may not be as new as he lets on/ a wolf for it

@Whysper

This makes me think Esquiddy isn’t very new. How can he say that Derps is always suspicious?

@Whysper

Oh okay, not completely new, but fairly new like me.

@Whysper

So do you think his push on you is just because he knows you the most and is suspicious about you in general?

As I said, she never pulls the trigger but implies that Squiddy is/may be wolfy because of it, as if trying to plant the seed in others rather than herself. Maybe I’m assuming she’s more skilled than she is, but wolves love to avoid blame for mislynches.

[Luxy]

@Marshal

Can you quote the “half of her ISO” talking about if Esquiddy is new. I see 2 posts, 1 questioning it and then 1 responding to being corrected and acknowledging that.

I was speaking in general her fixation on Squiddy

[Luxy]

Her opening was slightly better this game

[Chloe]

Accused	Voted by	Votes
SirDerpsAlot	Esquiddy	1/9
Trochilidae	Trochilidae	1/9
Surge	Surge	1/9
EliThePsycho	Insanity	1/9
Whysper	Luxy	1/9
Moleland	SirDerpsAlot, Alice, Jane, Marshal	4/9
Jane	Moleland	1/9
Not voting	EliThePsycho, Whysper, an_gorta_pratai, Appelsiini, PokemonKidRyan, Wazza	6

Sorry for delay in otecount

Lemme know if I fricked up

[SirDerpsAlot]

I’m just that gamer

[Marshal]

@Luxy

Posts suggesting Squiddy may not be as new as he lets on/ a wolf for it

@Luxy

@Whysper

This makes me think Esquiddy isn’t very new. How can he say that Derps is always suspicious?

@Whysper

Oh okay, not completely new, but fairly new like me.

@Whysper

So do you think his push on you is just because he knows you the most and is suspicious about you in general?

1, sure, that fits the bill

2 is literally admitting she is wrong

3. is mentioning derps/esquiddy knowing each other IRL

there’s 1 post. 1 post. 1 post and not the 21 like you implied is preeeeeeety hyperbolic my dude.

---

@Luxy

Posts mentioning Esquiddy:

@Whysper

Esquiddy & Jane - never played with them, so not familiar with their play styles

@Whysper

I’m not sure that I’d read it that way. Could also be an attempt to question why Derps would be out of the PoE. I’d say NAI.

@Whysper

Oh, I was actually wondering how new he is. He acted like a newbie in some regards, but he also talks about analyzing people as towny and scummy, so I don’t get the impression he’s completely new to the general game. Also, he voted for Derps pretty early on in his 4th post. That’s interesting. He gave no reasoning (which I think I will ask after this).

Also, Derps seems to be on a few lists for hard-to-read. So I think he might easily be put in the PoE.

@Whysper

Oh this is a good point too. Newb wolves still have partners.

@Whysper

This makes me think Esquiddy isn’t very new. How can he say that Derps is always suspicious?

@Whysper

Oh okay, not completely new, but fairly new like me.

@Whysper

So do you think his push on you is just because he knows you the most and is suspicious about you in general?

@Whysper

Yes, probably mostly that I haven’t seen him as wolf, though his town behavior comes off as wolfish due to not really helping and sometimes actually hindering like in FoL 30 that just ended. I checked SFoL 61 (I guess 61.5) and it appears he’s town there. I’ll search other games he’s been in.

@Whysper

Esquiddy - I originally had him a SL for his vote on Derps. There’s since been an explanation, so I’ve moved him up to null. He’ll possibly go into TL, but haven’t seen enough yet.

1. Literally just saying she’s never played with esquid
2. Saying something esquid did is NAI
3. Sure, that could be implying esquid is a good push
4. It was just recognizing that esquid could be coached. reaaaal strech but maybe.
5. I’ll give you this even if I disagree.
6. Addressed above, not calling esquid wolfy
7. Not actually calling esquid wofly
8. literally not talking about esquiddy in that post
9. Townleans esquiddy.

I’'ll say #3 and #5 fit the bill of pushing esquiddy, and #4 kind of does.

---

@Luxy

Half of her ISO is talking about whether esquiddy is ‘actually’ new or not

This assertion was off by about 95.2%.

And in only 2.5 posts did she imply esquiddy was a good lynch.

I think that you are full of shit. Feel free to keep trying to change my mind but rn I’m not convinced

[SirDerpsAlot]

/Vote Luxy

Ew

[Marshal]

/vote luxy

[Luxy]

Damn bro I exaggerated must be scum

In all seriousness I did look back and did realise I exaggerated but that was because I hated everything she posted content and tone-wise as seen in the large ISO of her I did, not just the stuff about Esquiddy. I don’t know why but in my head I remembered a lot more than what she actually did just because of the amount of things I disliked about her posts, made me overconflate it.

I’ll admit I’m wrong on the scale of the fixation on whether he is new or not, but they’re still pretty bad posts nonetheless.

[Luxy]

Even if I got one thing wrong there about the scale, theres still plenty of other reasons in my ISO of her of why she’s probably scum how does this condemn me at all @Marshal?