Watch Your Mouth!: Sophomore Year (3/17) - Day 5 - Planters (Mafia) Win!

good morning y’all!
i see my poems are being talked about and there’s one reason i did that: poet chili go brrrrr
i took it as a creative writing exercise
i might not be so bold tomorrow especially considering i’m a prime kill target so they might tailor the bomb to me

I never did state my reads. Also I told you myself I’m going to be less active for the time being and would be more active now. I’m here now and the only reason I had to disappear for a bit was to sort out my room but i’m here now.

I’ve read the entire thread, there’s just never anything for me to comment on so I just fade into the shadow again. When people tell me to do things, it makes me want to do them less even though I want to do things, I’m always asked at horrible times and that just lowers my WiM quality. I’m glad I saw this at a point where I actually have time to do things.
(Also please note, when I signed up, I knew I wasn’t going to be as active as a game like SFoL63)

I hope this is a good enough explanation for you.


I learnt how literally no one appreciates when someone tries to join in and help what people were assuming things and when I try to help, suddenly everyone turns it on me like I was the one suggesting it.

Anyway, I believe this is a good place to start to get people to actually either interact with me or give myself an opportunity to enter the thread.

This is ordered in the order of my reads instead of being ordered in alphabetical as I usually do:


Townread


Marshal
Alice
Gorta


Townlean


Surge (Something is clearly wrong) - If I’m townreading Surge, something isn’t right imo.
Appel
Chili
Whysper
Jane
PKR
Esquiddy


Null


Insanity
Moleland


Scumlean


Luxy
EliThePsycho


Any questions on my reads would be appreciated since then I have something to talk about. Thanks :+1:

1 Like

perhaps i haven’t read up far enough, but why is luxy so low in your list?

As of writing this post, it was her handling of the Trochilidae slot (asking her to chill on posts was something I was going to do), as well as her general tone surrounding the bomb.

because wolf is a super common FM word whereas mislynch is less common seeing as people want to phase out the word lynch. Hence the “probably”

Frozen means a player is not posting much or struggling in general to post when they can. basically a frozen player won’t know what to post and a player that isn’t frozen will be free-flowing with their posts.

The derps read was pure hedge, I wasn’t going for a conclusion, that post was meant to just post my internal thoughts on each slot and I had not reached an internal conclusion on derps.

She hadn’t made any more posts since the other one, reasoning above.


Alice is an easier read for me than derps, IMO. She has tonal differences that are actually pretty obvious but she will harass people into not pushing her if you try. And again she was of course in fringe towncore, which is a lean read in a post I made 250 posts in.

Derps I have misread so. many. fucking. times. He’s super difficult to discern for me. Homestuck and Hell in a Cell (I was a spectator but still called him super strong v) are ~recent examples of this. And while I liked his posting it’s not enough for me to towncore or even townlean him.


i disagree with a lot of this wall but i’m not going to just omgus wolfread it, just whatever, i have some game-related stuff I wanna do

He would be a Null due to low content and not really much to go off, but he’s instead a low Scumlean due to his disagreement with my read on Whypser.

this is understandable, though i don’t quite agree with SR’ing someone because they disagree with you

Like I said, he’s a null but also a low scumlean.

If someone disagrees with my reads on a player, I’ll bump them slightly down. Usually not enough to change a category, but I needed someone else to fill the space. Having only one scumlean makes it seems like I have a direct choice, you get me?

/unvote @DatBird @Chloe

also: here are some of my townreads at the moment
appel- panicky about my hella awesome poems, great discussion and flow, pushing for the thread to solve
marshal- again, can’t clear him for effort alone but i like their posts, especially how he points out flaws in others’ TRs of him
alice- what mainly stuck with me here was she pointed out she likely won’t survive long: i highly doubt she’d call attention to that so early as w

Read whysper’s past games and I don’t think that she’s an easy metaread atm

also i’ve done this in at least 5 seperate wolfgames, so this is not a good reason to read me. And don’t townread me for this either. Don’t read in to this, i’m just saying it’s not a good reason and shouldn’t be a reason to townread me ever

I don’t believe so either, I’m currently more than likely going to be townreading them since they seem townie with a townie attitude.

This isn’t a good reason, but good enough for me to trust players.

oh you have done this as w? interesting, i can see how it would work for you i’ll make note of that

My Never Execute Pool:

Marshal
Alice
Gorta
Appel
Chili
Whysper

My Go Ahead and Execute Pool:

Surge
Jane
PKR
Esquiddy
Insanity
Moleland
EliThePsycho

The lower you are, the more I want you exe’d

I am not the biggest fan of being 5th on your execute list.
But we will get to that hurdle when we will.

luxy is one of your top SR’s, yet you don’t want her exed? or was it a typo?

1 Like
List

Alice - Meh, pretty hard to explain.

Esquiddy

This feels like they genuinely believe that would help town. Their other posts are also somewhat pure.


Appelsiini - They’re going against strong players like Alice/Marshal and their thought process seems natural


Whysper - From my earlier interaction with them, I’m pretty sure they’re just weird town. I don’t really get why people are scumreading them tbh.

an_gorta_pratai - Their tone is decent, and they don’t seem very excited.


Insanity
Wazza
Surge
Marshal
Luxy
SirDerpsAlot
Trochilidae


EliThePsycho

They’re mostly here for these 2 posts, I don’t really think their other posts are AI. I do recall them making a similar “slip” in an earlier game, though.

Nvm, wasn’t as similar as I thought, their tone was more playful there.
Idk how much merit I want to put in this read tbh.


PokemonKidRyan - I’m basically sheeping Marshal’s reasoning on them.
Moleland - They don’t seem interested in solving the game at all.

Meh. The game’s been pretty boring so far. Most people have done very little.

1 Like

…yes, this is why I mean why your read is bad.

A) I was (badly) trying to conceal my identity then. I wouldn’t call myself a SPK or anything like that to attract my attention.

B) I meant dying n1 in relation to the bomb. I’m probably not going to live long this match so getting boom’d is not really that high in my mind.

C) Nobody begins two games the same way. I’ve never talked about being SPK’d as an opener as either V or W.

Marshal actually was very insistent on me not hyperposting, so it’s more like him showing genuine concern than in your case. As you can remember, I did not clear you for that then as the concern didn’t feel tht real. Also Marshal can’t be meta-read.

Meta-reads only work for a select players on this site, Marshal isn’t one of them.

He’s basically been clearing a lot of people but has been fairly hesitant on giving me a green light. That’s basically it.

Sorry, but your first read was pretty weh.

It’s Derps. He’s pretty much a wildcard.

That’s my b, Luxy was meant to be in there, for some reason I forgot my scumreads in there, caught that I missed out Eli but then for some reason forgot about Luxy.

uhh

do you mean alice

I don’t think i’ve commented on PKR

i figured but didn’t hurt to ask
also my thoughts on whysper:
i like her so far, she seems to be using her last wolf game to improve and help town more? again, her tone is quite different though so she’s pretty hard to read for me