That’s the thing that’s bothering me. They seemed adamant that they don’t need it at all.
After that revelation, this pretty much confirms that he is unconvertible. I have reasons to believe at the moment until otherwise, he could be BD rather than a neutral. He is actively scum hunting right now (well, was when they were here). I seem to have noticed in games with more experienced players, unconvertible BD classes tend to hunt more for scum, whereas the neutrals stay quiet. Maybe I’m wrong, and actually, this is a neutral trying to scum hunt. The issue there then is, if they are neutral, what can they be? Could they be NK, trying to blend in? Could they be something like an Alchemist, trying to get the attention of the BD to side with them or what have you. They could even be Fool trying to make themselves look active, push off a few mislynches and make us lynch them in response.
However, right now, my gut says they are BD.