I’m looking at Luxy next
@Luxy no
i shot nightingale last night
I’m not claiming anything other than that and that it is impossible for me to have been redirected
@Nightingale what if
you choose the yeet order for the 3 people after we yeet you
does this sound fair
- Luxy is acting differently from their previous Town game, Meowtainado (#2564, #2572)
- Close towards EoD2, Luxy was fine with lynching Zone over Eli, leaving the D1 wagons unresolved. This is detrimental to the Town, because almost the entire thread was tunneled on Eli; They weren’t ever going to clear themself and their flip was thus a needed reset. In Meowtainado, Luxy advocated strongly for lynching the counterwagon, stating it to be best mafia play.
- In Meowtainado, they strongly pushed for the lynches they thought were correct. (Which was mainly Cabbage, the previously stated counterwagon)
Here, they barely push any of their reads at all.
- Luxy’s progression on both Eli and Zone doesn’t make sense. (#2262, #2841, #2566)
- Close towards EoD1, when Eli was still the only wagon, they had them as a strong wolfread. However, when Pigeon became the counterwagon, they backtracked and claimed they had no strong opinion on either, and ended up voting Pigeon over Eli.
- Despite being confident that the scumteam was exacly Eli/Zone/gorta, they were only willing to swap to Zone if there was a case (Note that Wazza had already cased Zone). This contradicts their earlier claim that Zone was a better lynch because Eli’s lynch would provide almost no associations.
- Luxy’s scumread on Zone looks like textbook distancing (#2841)
- When they have narrowed their PoE down to Eli/gorta/Zone, they individually scumcase Eli. However, with Zone, they only use interactions with Eli and gorta (a villager and a likely villager) to paint Zone in a bad light, which can easily be backtracked if Zone would come under pressure.
After Zone’s wolf flip at the start of D3, they said “I told you Zone was a likely wolf” and disappeared until yet.
- When they have narrowed their PoE down to Eli/gorta/Zone, they individually scumcase Eli. However, with Zone, they only use interactions with Eli and gorta (a villager and a likely villager) to paint Zone in a bad light, which can easily be backtracked if Zone would come under pressure.
- Zone spew
- In #1962, Zone attacks Nightingale for scumreading Luxy, despite having not made a read on Luxy all game. This is a bad look for Luxy in light of Zone’s flip.
Minor additional points:
- Possible TMI:
- Near the start of D1, Luxy makes several leaps from very little content. I do not think they would instantly have these thoughts if they do not have TMI:
- In #516, they conclude me and cheese are T v T, based on #107 and #135.
- in #520 and #600, they conclude that gorta’s post was not a perspective slip, but instead them being used to being voted out specifically as a Villager based on #219, #223 and #225
- In #1297, when stating that the game feels too easy, they include themself in a triple of potential powerwolves.
- They then use this to justify Emilia’s RT despite proclaiming earlier that they gained no meaningful information from it; and also ignoring that they randomly picked three strong players at the start of the game, when only 1 of them had posted. It may have made sense at the point when Luxy said that, but it definitely did not at the start of the game. (#1301, #1991)
Anecdotal evidence, doesn't add much to the case
While they can also come from villagers, comments like these usually come from wolves. This is especially true since cloned was a cop.
Potential Freudian slip 
2 Likes
the comments on Zone, defense of my slot, the pushing of Eli all make me think Luxy is scum here
Official Votecount
| Voted | Voter | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Luxy | Jane, min | 2/5 |
| Emilia | Night | 1/5 |
| Not Voting | Emilia, Silviu, Luxy, Gorta, Marl | 5 |
literalyly no because that means i have to confidently nail the exact team when you could just
not ego-exe me?
like, you need to clear two people from luxy/me/emilia/jane/gorta
if you wont to execute me you better be pretty confident that one of luxy/emilia/jane are a villager because im not willing to stake the game on any of those three slots
when jane
makes a case on
luxy and you
are sleepy
so you dont get
any of the cred
1 Like
also yes gorta was blockde
this doestn mention trackers explicitly like the other one does
like it literally says “alignment checks” there is no possible way that you could twist that