you could have at least done another tiny wallpost thing like you did in meowntainado
i was laughing at that for a while
this time Eli doesn’t have a plan
“well i had a wallpost”
>literally 2 posts
i think that’d be counterproductive tbh
i forgot how funny this was LMAO
OH RIGHT I remembered another thing I didn’t like about Wendy this is 1 post but it’s like, completely out of place in the thread context, it’s posted as literally post 47 (21 minutes into the game), no one was remotely close to the postcap it feels like the sort of posts wolves who don’t know what to say make just to sound “”“pro-town”""
wait holy shit
anyone who started ragging on Chloe for the post count thing basically repeated what a wolf said in another game
huh
I skimmed to catch up and will respond to things in more detail later but there’s something i wanted to say before i lose the thought
@staypositivefriend This feels kinda like a c4 CoV moment
Not with regards to your alignment but someone else’s
If you get me you get me
If you don’t then oh well I’ll explain later
and
It’s a fucking awful look for the people who were pushing Chloe initially
which I don’t really remember but I think Alice is one of them
I have to get dinner soon but I’ll check later
A N D ?
Actually the more I think about it
It isn’t that bad really
Because without more context Arete could’ve actually said that for a bunch of reasons which don’t apply
and from what I remember I don’t think Wendy was a consensus scumread like Chloe was at start of day 1
Like I think Arete more used it to just point a finger at Wendy while chloe got dog piled for it
so I’m not sure how wolfy it actually is
Proph I think is wolfy because overall he’s taken a much more reactive take towards thread, he isn’t actually trying to steer the ship, more just try to react to whatever the ship throws at him. To me at least from the type of player I think Proph is I think that is very wolfy, I think overall if a very experienced player is taking a more reactive approach to thread then it’s most likely they’re a wolf because it shows that they have TMI and aren’t actually solving.
Overall I think this is mostly exemplified by his start of day, generally I find that almost all of the wolves start posting during the start of the day because they want to get their hooks into thread and perhaps influence it in a way that fits wolf agenda. Because of this generally I look for the person with the weakest opener when I’m wolf hunting and Proph fits this, most of his early posts felt exactly like he was just trying to get his claws into thread in any way he could, rather than actually solve.
Secondly, the progression on a lot of his reads feel very weak, I don’t understand a lot of his progression and I don’t understand how he got his reads and why. It feels like he had some semi good reasons for townreading Vulgard that he suddenly dropped for no real reason. Overall it felt more like a sudden tunnel to look productive rather than actually solving.
there is that good enough
Ghana, it’s barely been 24 hours since this game began, and I was away for most of the early interaction that took place (the first four or five hours). I feel like I’ve been stuck in perpetual catch-up mode because the weekends are generally busy for me and it’s been difficult to fully respond to everyone and keep up with the game. Hence why I’ve been mainly wallposting for the past 24 hours. If this game started on like a Monday, then that’d be different.
I also don’t know why you think I’ve been reactive when I’ve been trying to interrogate and actively weigh Vulgard’s alignment in my head for the past 18 or so hours. I’ve been working with Arctic/Chloe/Alice and so on to hash out reads (and admittedly yes I have been asking about meta, but that’s because I am unfamiliar with some players) and I don’t think that’s me being reactive.
Also don’t understand you scumreading me for my SoD. I went to vote in RVS and then tried to finish a boss fight in the video game I was playing. After that, I was planning on posting, but I had some unexpected RL duties I had to attend to so I couldn’t really start playing/interacting until later that Saturday. Why is that wolfy?
Finally wrt the progression on my reads, I think I’ve been playing pretty transparently and I think between my three catchup posts and my reads posts you can get a sense of where my head is at with regards to my reads. With specifically Vulgard, I asked him a lot of questions to figure out where he was at, saw the Chloe post, agreed with it, and decided to pressure him because of it.
I was expecting some responses to my questions from earlier when he reappeared in thread, but then he said that he was intentionally overexplaining his read on Chloe/spf, and then he said that his read on Chloe/spf were all town because of “depth of thought”. I wanted some actual progression coming from him instead of the about-face he did a couple of hours ago - that’s why I honed in on him.
i don’t think she did
i’m pretty sure it was literally only vulgard that did it
i pointed out how cabbage got scumread for a similar thing in meowntainado but vulgard said it was wolfy because it was specifically chloe pointing it out and then didn’t explain why
It’s a fucking awful look for the people who were pushing Chloe initially
why
I feel like I’m kinda clogging up the thread with my wallposts to/from Ghana so I’m gonna stop that rn
I know a couple of people have @'d me with specific Qs, I’ll try to address those and then try to focus on other slots
Ghana, if you think I’m a wolf, just keep tunneling me I guess. Legitimately have no clue what to think about your alignment anymore, I’ll try to come back to you when I’ve cooled off a bit
i think i know what you’re trying to get at. do you actually think that’s the case?
does everyone currently in the thread mind sharing the strongest reads that they have in either direction? it would be super helpful to me rn
Firstly to me your opener felt wolfy because to me it looked like a wolf who struggled with making a natural looking opener, it felt very fake and like you were posting for the sake of posting without any thoughts going through your head.
It felt like you wanted to be anywhere else but you felt like you had to look good initially in thread
Secondly your progression on reads,
it’s ironic that you basically proved my point exactly in that section
I have literally no clue what any of your other reads are or why you have them
Literally those two paragraphs you just posted were just you throwing shit at Vulgard, to me it looks like you just spinned a wheel and decided Vulgard would be an easy slot to push so you could get away with not having to post anything
This is the pot calling the kettle black but why haven’t I seen more from you? Like I hope everyone else has a general idea of my other reads other than you being wolfy but I can’t say the same about you
I also don’t know why you think I’ve been reactive when I’ve been trying to interrogate and actively weigh Vulgard’s alignment in my head for the past 18 or so hours. I’ve been working with Arctic/Chloe/Alice and so on to hash out reads (and admittedly yes I have been asking about meta, but that’s because I am unfamiliar with some players) and I don’t think that’s me being reactive.
Like your entire initial scumread on Vulgard felt like just you reacting to general thread state
You haven’t even been pushing consensus reads or anything like that, you’ve just been pushing Vulgard
You aren’t even being active in trying to keep the status quo the same, you reacted to the push on Vulgard and that’s all you’ve done