isn’t this literally indicative of him being a wolf
idk, if i remembered i’d have a much better idea of how to interpret vulgard’s play tbh
no
that’s the pattern that followed me in ciconia when i was openwolfing
only 2 players jumped to vote me despite basically the entire thread calling me scum with marshal stepping in and whiteknighting me
i think marl also defended you and he was a wolf
if this is the case then do you think it makes gghana likely to be a wolf?
ok arctic enough with this shit
me questioning why the thread was scumreading Vulgard is not me townreading him
Marl came in super late, even later than you, and didn’t even give a read on me until Chloe said she was surprised Marl didn’t immediately jump to add me to the hood chat, and even then he picked me without voicing a read until I asked. I meant when I was liveposting in the thread, though. I had cut out the openwolfing act by the time you and Marl posted.
bruh u literally said you townread him
and your reasons were pretty shit i’m gonna be honest
2 Likes
Ghana, chill. I’m trying to catch up from post 600 or so and will get to your case in a bit. Just been preoccupied with house tasks in between posts
I mean, I know your read on me is bad because I’m town. I was waffling a little bit on Vulgard because the more I thought about his earlier posts, the more it didn’t make sense coming from him as either alignment. And why do you think I am being creative with his interpretation of what he posted? I know I paraphrased a little bit, but it was pretty much what Vul said.
This is not true. I think the people who have explicitly called me out like that are Chloe, you, spf, Ghana, and Alice
Only people who I’m townreading in that group now are you and Chloe. Ghana has dropped down to a “need to spend more time on” read and spf/Alice are also in my group to read later
I was asking spf/Alice to potentially interact with me more about that read last night
I agree with you on this. I’m not saying that you’re scumreading me for having consensus reads, I’m saying that you’re wrong about my reads being vapid.
I literally posted all of those reads in my post 396, which was really close to the timeline where I made my catchup walls. I’m not pushing this stuff now - those were my reads from a day ago.
In my catchup posts, I was indeed a little unsure if Vulg could be a wolf or not - I was more observing behaviors from him that was weird from him as either alignment. That’s why I asked him those questions - so I could get a better bead on him. I think the thing you’re missing with my progression was this part in my third catchup post:
That’s sorta when my read coalesced from “Vulg is making this read in bad faith or overplaying it as a villager” to the former instead of the latter.
Got it, thanks. Will be tracking that then
Like I had some gut pangs that he might be villagery, but I could see him flipping whatever and I wanted to know more on why thread scumread him
but the fact that you keep twisting my words because you can’t even be bothered to read what I say is honestly getting insanely irritating at this point
this game feels to me like a series of 1 v 1 conversations as opposed to a ~broader~ conversation that everyone is participating in. it’s like the spotlight changes every 50-100 posts to focus on an exchange between two new players
i don’t say this as a criticism, but it does explain why i’m kinda having trouble getting a solid foundation for my reads in this game. i might need to treat it more like chat mafia and just focus on interrogating people in real time
i think that arctic is a villager (and he’s probably my most confident village read ATM). i’m leaning on alice and leafia being villagers as well. i have mixed thoughts about the rest of the playerlist but the good news is that i think this game is easily solvable through flips (ie: a vulgard red flip would clear chloe, an alice red flip would clear gghana, etc)
1 Like
also, i think that emilia is wolfy because it came off like she was forcing herself to post in the thread the longer the game has been going. her posts feel relatively passionless to me. is this typical for her town meta?
uwu~
1 Like
What does your third catch-up post have to do with anything
You keep trying to misrepresent my thoughts about a specific paragraph as my entire case and the more you do this shit the more wolfy it looks because to me it looks like I have you dead to rights and you’re too scared to actually interact with my case
I’ve made my thoughts very clear on why I wolf read you, in a concise way that can’t be misunderstood. I think I have misread some of your posts so because of that I decided to put all my thoughts into two concise posts.
Why do you keep ignoring them to argue with me about a read I had a day ago that I barely remember.
I’ve only been in the thread for like an hour or so and I’m seeing exactly what you pointed out here lol
I don’t think it’s a bad thing and it’s probably conducive to solving since it focuses on a couple slots at a time? but Iike, a couple people are currently in the thread and only Arctic and Leafia have talked with me so far.
Just gimme a sec
I’m just catching up and trying to respond to all of your posts where you interacted with me earlier in the day
You keep trying to argue with me about my specific thoughts about you and Vulgard but literally not once have you even brought up these posts
That’s why I think you’re arguing in bad faith, if you actually wanted to convince everyone you were town instead of just trying to shut me up you would’ve addressed literally anything in these posts